Medicolegal Issues

When the Biggest Mistake Yields the Smallest Impact

Multiple missteps led to a missed diagnosis. Whose fault (and financial penalty) is greatest?

Author and Disclosure Information

 

References

In February 2007, a 65-year-old man consulted an internist. A blood test showed an infection. Antibiotics were administered successfully, and the patient was declared free of infection. He was noted to have a heart murmur, however, prompting the internist to refer him to a cardiologist, Dr K., for an echocardiogram.

But the internist’s nurse practitioner provided the wrong clinical indication for the referral. As a result, Dr K., unaware of what to look for, read the echocardiogram as negative. The internist and NP did not realize the mistake, because they never requested a copy of the results.

The internist later sent the patient to an infectious disease (ID) specialist, Dr G., to rule out endocarditis. Dr G.’s opinion was that there was no infection.

The patient’s condition deteriorated, however, and he was admitted to a hospital in early May 2007. Two day later, he was diagnosed with endocarditis. He subsequently underwent open-heart surgery and received antibiotics. He died later that month.

Continue for the outcome and David Lang's comments >>

Pages

Recommended Reading

Experts See Larger Role for CDC in Preventing Hospital Deaths
Clinician Reviews
A Diabetic Foot Infection Progresses to Amputation
Clinician Reviews
Settling a Malpractice Suit Is Seldom a Straightforward Decision
Clinician Reviews
Social Media Can Help, Harm Liability Cases
Clinician Reviews
In Child Abuse Case, Everyone Fails
Clinician Reviews
Judges Reveal Secrets to Successful Malpractice Trials
Clinician Reviews
A Cocktail of Medications Leads to Death
Clinician Reviews
The Five “I’s” of Electronic Health Records
Clinician Reviews
Malpractice Reform Failed to Curb Defensive Medicine in the ED
Clinician Reviews
Hospitalists Shine in Study of Heart Failure Outcomes
Clinician Reviews