In March 2021, Prime Minister Boris Johnson proposed a 1% pay rise for National Health Service (NHS) workers in the United Kingdom — a move many deemed inadequate after a full year of fighting the COVID-19 pandemic. The next day, James Cowe, a 23-year-old healthcare assistant who had been working in dementia care for 6 years, decided to create a profile on the content subscription site OnlyFans.
The London-based site allows subscribers, or “fans,” to request content, making its name distributing nude pictures, videos, and other sexually explicit content. It garnered mainstream attention in 2020 when housebound individuals and even celebrities began using it to generate income. Back in August, OnlyFans released a statement stating that it would ban “sexually explicit” content beginning in October. Days later, the company recanted the statement after uproar from creators.
“Because of the one-percent pay rise, I’ve started OnlyFans and I’m making more money in three days than I make in a month at work,” Mr. Cowe said in a now-deleted TikTok post. “Sorry Boris, but I’m done with healthcare and now I’m an online whore.”
Mr. Cowe earned the equivalent of a year’s salary from his healthcare assistant job in his first 22 days on OnlyFans.
Stories like his have multiplied during the pandemic, at a time when healthcare professionals have been particularly overworked and particularly essential. Meanwhile, the pandemic has exacerbated challenges for many sex workers across the globe.
“[There have been] many, many reports over history that transactional sex is used as a sort of emergency livelihood strategy in all kinds of emergencies,” says Joanne Csete, PhD, associate professor of population and family health at Columbia University, New York, “and I suppose this is an emergency in that sense, like any other.”
The relationship between sex work and healthcare
A 2015 study by Leeds University found that 70% of sex workers in the United Kingdom previously worked in healthcare, charities, or education and that more than a third held university degrees.
The relationship between sex workers and healthcare workers has historically been disconnected. Sex workers are at higher risk of experiencing violence, sexually transmitted infections, and substance abuse and mental health problems than the general population, as noted by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. But according to the UN Population Fund, 63% of sex workers will not seek health services alone because they are distrustful and fearful of healthcare workers. A 2014 study by UNAIDS found that stigmatization also makes sex workers less likely to seek assistance from social services.
“I think it’s almost universally hard for sex workers to get respectful healthcare without judgment, and in some cases actual hostility, because of the stigma of their work,” Dr. Csete says. “Health workers are not always trained to see sex work as anything but either a criminal act or an immoral act.”
In August 2021, U.K. medical students called for the British Medical Association to protect students from being penalized by or expelled from their universities for engaging in sex work. BMA Medical Students Committee chair Becky Bates cited high medical school fees and a lack of financial support as motivations for student sex workers. She told this news organization that sex work often allows for flexible hours that might make it easier for students to balance the demands of medical school than other part-time jobs would.
At the annual BMA conference in September, two thirds of the association’s doctors voted in favor of the motion, while others criticized it as potential encouragement for students to get involved in sex work. “The motion isn’t about the morality of sex work,” Ms. Bates said. “[It’s] about the fact that it’s happening and what we can do to support students.”