Commentary

The other epidemic: Violence against health care workers


 

After working two busy evening hospital shifts, I was eating breakfast with my children when I started reading about physicians confronted and verbally abused during school board meetings for advocating for face masks in school. The pandemic changed course with the Delta variant increasing hospitalizations, and it seems to me the public response to physicians and health care workers also changed.

During the first wave of the pandemic, public support accompanied health care workers’ sacrifices. Nightly applause rang through New York City, there were donations of food, and murals reflected public backing.

We as a nation rallied. We masked up and locked down. We produced vaccines. COVID cases decreased, and by spring, a hint of normalcy bloomed.

Then the virus changed, and the Delta variant spread. Pandemic fatigue set in. Health care workers asked for help with continued masking and increased vaccinations and instead were met with threats. The summer, already made difficult, makes the prospect of winter even more daunting.

This kind of abuse is persistent

Violence against health care workers is not a new dilemma. Stories abound of patients or family members physically attacking, verbally abusing, or harassing health care workers. A 2014 survey reported almost 80% of nurses attacked during their career. Data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics also reveals health care workers experience more nonfatal workplace violence, as compared with other professions.

Nurses, who often spend the most face-to-face time with patients, receive a litany of abuse. A 2019 nursing survey reported 59% of respondents experiencing verbal abuse from patients and more than 43% experiencing verbal abuse from patients’ families. Even more concerning is 23% of survey respondents reporting physical abuse, an increase from 20% in 2018.

Physicians, likewise, are not immune from the same maltreatment. A 2014 physician survey reported more than 71% of physicians in the United States have experienced at least one incident of workplace violence in their careers. Of the physician specialties, the highest rates of violence are in the emergency department and against less experienced physicians. This is likely caused by the higher rates of patient frustration in EDs as a result of long wait times, overcrowding, and boarding while awaiting an inpatient room.

These statistics are disheartening. However, what I find most discouraging is the almost submissive acceptance of this abuse in the health care field as almost 73% of health care workers feel that the abuse is part of the job.

COVID and the increase in violence against health care workers

The specter of COVID-19 has not only increased the problem of violence toward health care workers but has accelerated it at an alarming rate. As the Delta variant spreads, hospitals’ capacity to handle both COVID and non-COVID issues is further strained. Compounding this stress is the public’s pandemic fatigue and the ongoing battles with masking and vaccinations.

In San Antonio, health care workers faced verbal and physical abuse as they enforced masking and visitation restrictions for COVID patients. Online, health care workers, who advocate for masking or vaccination, are often subject to death threats, threats to family members, and verbal abuse on social media. Veiled threats of “we know who you are” and “we will find you” follow physicians who advocate for masking in schools.

This problem is not isolated to the United States. In Italy, a COVID patient spat at health care workers who asked them to wait, resulting in closure of an entire hospital ward. In the United Kingdom, health care workers were subject to the same abuse as those in San Antonio when trying to enforce masking in the hospital. In India, Pakistan, and Spain, a stigma exists against health care workers for being sources of contagion.

The presence of a growing divide between health care workers and those we serve threatens to undermine not only delivery of care but also our response to the pandemic. This is in addition to the mental health burden and compassion fatigue suffered by many health care workers who find their efforts in doubt. An already strained medical system will find it difficult to withstand the loss of its essential workforce.

Pages

Recommended Reading

What is the real risk of smart phones in medicine?
Federal Practitioner
Affirming Pride
Federal Practitioner
The Gut-Brain Axis: Literature Overview and Psychiatric Applications
Federal Practitioner
It’s time for all physicians to have a national medical license
Federal Practitioner
Pathology society first to call for nationwide vaccination mandate
Federal Practitioner
Three Primary Cancers in a Veteran With Agent Orange and Agent Blue Exposures
Federal Practitioner
An Interdisciplinary Approach to Metastatic Pancreatic Cancer and Comorbid Opioid Use Disorder Treatment Within a VA Health Care System
Federal Practitioner
Bone Health in Patients With Prostate Cancer: An Evidence-Based Algorithm
Federal Practitioner
‘Countdown to zero’: Endocrine disruptors and worldwide sperm counts
Federal Practitioner
The secret I’ll take to my grave: Doc reveals
Federal Practitioner