Commentary

When Patients Make Unexpected Medical Choices

Author and Disclosure Information

 

References

Neuroplasticity changes can contribute to chronic pain that may also lead to depression.23 Chronic pain and depression may involve the same brain structures, neurotransmitters, and signaling pathway.23 Factors leading to chronic pain and depression include decreased availability of monoamine neurotransmitters, such as serotonin, dopamine, and norepinephrine in the central nervous system, decreased brain-derived neurotrophic factor, inflammatory response, and increased glutamate activity.23 Depression and hopelessness have been associated with the desire to hasten death among patients with a terminal illness.24 Worse mental health has been associated with the desire to hasten death among patients who are older and functionally impaired.25 It was important to optimize Mr. S’s treatment for pain and depression to ensure that these factors were not influencing his medical decisions.

With increasing recognition of the need to improve quality of life, health care utilization, and provide care consistent with patients’ goals in nephrology, the concept of renal PC is emerging but remains limited.26 The need to improve supportive care or PC for patients starting on dialysis for ESRD is high as these patients tend to be older (aged > 75 years), have high rates of cardiovascular comorbidities, can have coexisting cognitive impairment and functional debility, and have an adjusted mortality rate of up to 32.5% within 1 year of starting dialysis.26 Some ways to enhance renal PC programs include incorporating PC skill development and training within nephrology fellowships, educating patients with chronic and ESRD about PC and options for medical management without dialysis, and increasing the collaboration between nephrology and PC.26

Outcomes and Implications

Respect for the ethical principle of autonomy is paramount in health care. Patients should be able to give informed consent for treatment decisions without undue influence from their HCPs and should be able to withdraw that consent at any point during treatment. Factors that may influence patients’ ability to make medical decisions should be considered, including untreated or poorly treated symptoms. The involvement of PC helps optimize symptom management, provide support, and assist in goals-of-care discussions. Advanced practice PC nurses can offer other members of the health care team additional information and support in end-of-life care. Family involvement should be encouraged even for patients who can make their own medical decisions for emotional support and to assist families in what could be a traumatic event, such as the loss of a loved one.

The desire to pursue a comfort-focused approach to terminal illness and stop disease-modifying treatments are criteria for hospice care. An interdisciplinary approach to end-of-life care is beneficial, and every specialty should be equipped to engage in honest communication and skillful prognostication. These conversations should start early in the course of a terminal illness. Multiple factors contribute to poor clinical outcomes among patients with ESRD even with renal replacement therapy, such as dialysis. There is a need to improve PC training in the field of nephrology.

Conclusions

Mr. S was able to choose to withdraw potentially life-prolonging treatments with the support of his family and HCPs. He was able to continue receiving high-quality care and treatment in accordance with his wishes and goals for his care. The provision of interdisciplinary care that focused on supporting him allowed for his peaceful and comfortable death.

Pages

Recommended Reading

Mindfulness, exercise strike out in memory trial
Federal Practitioner
New test that detects 14 cancers focuses on sugars, not DNA
Federal Practitioner
Bad breath? Mouthwash is out. Yogurt is in.
Federal Practitioner
Genetic test identifies parental source of cancer variant
Federal Practitioner
Study of beliefs about what causes cancer sparks debate
Federal Practitioner
Medical practice gave 8,000 patients cancer for Christmas
Federal Practitioner
Small study finds high dose vitamin D relieved toxic erythema of chemotherapy
Federal Practitioner
Five thoughts on the Damar Hamlin collapse
Federal Practitioner
Cancer clinics begin to accommodate patients demanding new cancer detection tests
Federal Practitioner
Chronic pain patients swapping opioids for medical cannabis
Federal Practitioner