From the Journals

Distinct suicidal thought patterns flag those at highest risk


 

FROM THE JOURNAL OF CLINICAL PSYCHIATRY

Long-term assessment of suicide risk and ideation in older adults may help identify distinct ideation patterns and predict potential future suicidal behavior, new research suggests.

Investigators studied over 300 older adults, assessing suicidal ideation and behavior for up to 14 years at least once annually. They then identified four suicidal ideation profiles.

They found that risk of suicide attempt/death was almost five times greater for chronic severe ideators and more than three times greater for highly variable ideators, compared with fast-remitting ideators. In turn, fast-remitting ideators were at higher risk in comparison to low/nonideators with no attempts or suicide.

Chronic severe ideators also showed the most severe levels of dysfunction across personality, social characteristics, and impulsivity measures, while highly variable and fast-remitting ideators displayed more specific deficits.

“We identified longitudinal ideation profiles that convey differential risk of future suicidal behavior to help clinicians recognize high suicide risk patients for preventing suicide,” said lead author Hanga Galfalvy, PhD, associate professor, department of psychiatry, Columbia University Irving Medical Center, New York.

“Clinicians should repeatedly assess suicidal ideation and ask not only about current ideation but also about the worst ideation since the last visit [because] similar levels of ideation during a single assessment can belong to very different risk profiles,” said Dr. Galfalvy, also a professor of biostatistics and a coinvestigator in the Conte Center for Suicide Prevention at Columbia University.

The study was published online in the Journal of Clinical Psychiatry.

Vulnerable population

“Older adults in most countries, including the U.S., are at the highest risk of dying of suicide out of all age groups,” said Dr. Galfalvy. “A significant number of depressed older adults experience thoughts of killing themselves, but fortunately, only a few transition from suicidal thoughts to behavior.”

Senior author Katalin Szanto, MD, professor of psychiatry, University of Pittsburgh, said in an interview that currently established clinical and psychosocial suicide risk factors have “low predictive value and provide little insight into the high suicide rate in the elderly.”

These traditional risk factors “poorly distinguish between suicide ideators and suicide attempters and do not take into consideration the heterogeneity of suicidal behavior,” said Dr. Szanto, principal investigator at the University of Pittsburgh’s Longitudinal research Program in Late-Life Suicide, where the study was conducted.

“Suicidal ideation measured at one time point – current or lifetime – may not be enough to accurately predict suicide risk,” the investigators wrote.

The current study, a collaboration between investigators from the Longitudinal Research Program in Late-Life Suicide and the Conte Center for Suicide Prevention, investigates “profiles of suicidal thoughts and behavior in patients with late-life depression over a longer period of time,” Dr. Galfalvy said.

The researchers used latent profile analysis (LPA) in a cohort of adults with nonpsychotic unipolar depression (aged 50-93 years; n = 337; mean age, 65.12 years) to “identify distinct ideation profiles and their clinical correlates” and to “test the profiles’ association with the risk of suicidal behavior before and during follow-up.”

LPA is “a data-driven method of grouping individuals into subgroups, based on quantitative characteristics,” Dr. Galfalvy explained.

The LPA yielded four profiles of ideation.

Ideator subgroups in latent profile analysis

At baseline, the researchers assessed the presence or absence of suicidal behavior history and the number and lethality of attempts. They prospectively assessed suicidal ideation and attempts at least once annually thereafter over a period ranging from 3 months to 14 years (median, 3 years; IQR, 1.6-4 years).

At baseline and at follow-ups, they assessed ideation severity.

Assessment of suicidal ideation

They also assessed depression severity, impulsivity, and personality measures, as well as perception of social support, social problem solving, cognitive performance, and physical comorbidities.

Pages

Recommended Reading

Sleep complaints in major depression flag risk for other psychiatric disorders
Federal Practitioner
Guidelines recommend CBT alone for mild acute depression, more options for more severe cases
Federal Practitioner
Depression guidelines fall short in characterizing withdrawal
Federal Practitioner
Depression and schizophrenia: Many biological and clinical similarities
Federal Practitioner
Psychiatric illnesses share common brain network
Federal Practitioner
Long-term depression may hasten brain aging in midlife
Federal Practitioner
Loneliness risk elevated among young cancer survivors
Federal Practitioner
TMS tied to ‘marked’ antidepressant, anxiolytic effects in anxious depression
Federal Practitioner
Repetitive TMS effective for comorbid depression, substance use
Federal Practitioner
What’s new in brain health?
Federal Practitioner