The report card
Federal government efforts in regulation of tobacco products, taxation, and health insurance coverage of cessation all received an F in this report, while mass media campaigns were given an A.
The states didn’t fare much better. They were graded on prevention and control funding, smoke-free air, taxation, access to cessation services, and minimum age for sales. A total of 19 states received a grade of F in four or five of these areas.
Funding for prevention and control was evaluated as the percentage of the amount recommended by the CDC, adjusted for a variety of state-specific factors such as prevalence of tobacco use, cost and complexity of conducting mass media campaigns, and proportion of the audience below 200% of the federal poverty level. A limitation of this methodology of grading funding is that it doesn’t evaluate effectiveness of the spending or the level of spending in different program categories. The higher spenders on prevention and control were Alaska at 98.1% and California at 74.5% of the CDC recommended level. The lowest spenders were Georgia at 2.8% and Missouri at 3.0%.
All but eight states received an F on minimum age for tobacco sales because most have an age limit 18 instead of the ALA and CDC recommendation of age 21.
Harold Wimmer, the CEO of the American Lung Association, wrote, “Aggressive action by our country’s federal and state policymakers is urgently required. However, ‘State of Tobacco Control’ 2019 has found a disturbing failure by federal and state governments to take action to put in place meaningful and proven-effective policies that would have prevented, and reduced tobacco use during 2018. This failure to act places the lung health and lives of Americans at risk. We have also found that this lack of action has emboldened tobacco companies to be even more brazen in producing and marketing products squarely aimed at kids, such as the JUUL e-cigarettes that look like an easily concealed USB drive, which now dominate the market driven by youth use.”
The full report is available for download at the ALA website.
SOURCE: American Lung Association, “State of Tobacco Control 2019”.