CHICAGO – Early palliative care delivered almost exclusively by telephone improved survival among patients with advanced cancer in the ENABLE III study.
After a median follow-up of a little more than 1 year, 46% of patients receiving palliative care from the time of cancer diagnosis and 54% of those with delayed palliative care had died.
Dr. Marie Bakitas
Overall median survival was 18.3 months for the immediate group and 11.9 months for the delayed group (P = .17).
In preplanned analyses, the risk of death at 1 year was significantly lower in the immediate group (hazard ratio 0.72; P = .003), with a catch-up effect thereafter, Marie Bakitas, DNSc, reported at the annual meeting of the American Society of Clinical Oncology.
"Enhanced medical care, reduced aggressive care and chemotherapy use, longer access to hospice, and biologic impacts of improved quality of life have all been proposed as mechanisms to explain this survival advantage," Dr. Bakitas said. "However, at the present time, we do not have the data to support a particular mechanism and we are actively exploring this question through secondary analyses."
ENABLE (Educate, Nurture, Advise, Before Life Ends) III is the first study to examine the timing of early palliative care, but not the first to identify a survival advantage.
A recent study (N. Engl. J. Med. 2010:363:733-42) found that patients with metastatic non–small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) who received palliative care at the time of randomization lived a significant 2.7 months longer than did those receiving standard oncologic care, despite receiving significantly less aggressive end-of-life care (33% vs. 54%).
In ENABLE III, 207 patients with advanced cancer, and their caregivers, were randomized as a dyad to begin usual cancer care plus the intervention at the time of diagnosis (immediate group) or usual care alone for 3 months followed by the intervention (delayed group).
The intervention consisted of a traditional outpatient palliative care consult and six weekly structured telephone calls with a nurse coach using a guidebook that covers such topics as problem solving, symptom management, communication, and advanced care planning, explained Dr. Bakitas, the Marie O’Koren Endowed Chair and Professor, School of Nursing, and associate director of the Center for Palliative and Supportive Care, University of Alabama, Birmingham.
Usual care included the clinical consult, but not the telephone intervention.
The participants’ mean age was 64 years, half were male, 60% lived in a rural area, and 65% were married or living with a partner. Lung cancer was the most common diagnosis at 42%.
At baseline, 75% of patients were receiving chemotherapy, 19% were undergoing radiation, and 43% had an advanced directive completed at diagnosis.
Unlike the group’s prior trial comparing palliative care to usual care at 3 months, immediate versus delayed palliative care did not lead to significant improvements in quality of life on the Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness Therapy-Palliative care scale (129.9 vs. 127.2; P = .34), mood on the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression scale (11.2 vs. 10.8; P = .33), or symptom impact on the Quality of Life at the End of Life symptom impact subscale (11.4 vs. 12.2; P = .09).
One plausible reason for the findings is that there may not have been enough care differences between the two groups, with 40% of the delayed group receiving their first palliative care contact an average of 30 days before they were scheduled to do so on day 84, Dr. Bakitas said.
Second, difficulties in accrual and decreased study power may have made it difficult to pick up between-group differences on the subjective instruments, resulting in a type 2 error.
"A 3-month delay is still very early," Dr. Bakitas said.
She noted that early intervention allowed the palliative care team to have contact with patients for 1 year on average (range 240-493 days), compared with a median of 41-90 days from referral to death reported for outpatient clinics in a national survey of 142 National Cancer Institute and non-NCI cancer centers (JAMA 2010;303:1054-61).
Resource and chemotherapy use in ENABLE III was also comparable in both groups. Decedents in the immediate and delayed groups spent a median of 5 and 6 days, respectively, in hospital in the 7-9 months preceding death, while 8% and 5% received chemotherapy in the last 2 weeks of life.
This compares favorably with a national average of more than 8 hospital days in the last 6 months of life observed in the 2014 Dartmouth Atlas of Health Care, and a chemotherapy rate of 17.5% reported in the previously noted NSCLC study, Dr. Bakitas said.