DENVER — Physicians may not be enamored of Medicare, but they like it better than private insurance plans, according to a survey by the Medical Group Management Association.
In MGMA's Payer Performance Study—covering more than 1,700 group practices—physician groups ranked Medicare Part B well ahead of six large private insurers in terms of overall satisfaction. The survey asked members of MGMA to rank seven of the largest payers (Medicare Part B, UnitedHealthcare, Aetna, Cigna, Humana, Coventry, and Anthem) on payer communications, provider credentialing, contract negotiation, payment processing, systems transparency, and overall satisfaction.
Medicare led the pack with a mean aggregate satisfaction score of 3.59 on a 6-point scale. Aetna took second place with a score of 3.14. The big loser? UnitedHealthcare, with a score of 2.45.
Medicare scored particularly well on the amount of time it takes to respond to questions from physicians or practice managers, the accuracy of its responses, and transparency in disclosing fee schedules and reimbursement policies.
The respondents were much less satisfied with Medicare's provider-credentialing processes. On that measure, Medicare ranked last, with Aetna and Anthem taking first and second place. “The Medicare credentialing process is completely out of synch with that of the private payers, and it is a problem,” said Dr. William Jessee, president and chief executive officer of MGMA, which released the data at its annual meeting.
The data show particularly strong member dissatisfaction with the private insurers on contract negotiation. “MGMA members feel there is disproportionate power on the side of the payers,” Dr. Jessee said.
The MGMA survey did not ask about satisfaction with actual Medicare reimbursement rates, but Dr. Jessee said he anticipated that Medicare's ranking could drop considerably if the federal government cuts physician fees in the future.
Medical group operating costs have been rising at an average rate of 6.5% per year for the last decade, yet Medicare reimbursement has been flat. That, Dr. Jessee said, is making it difficult for many groups to stay in business. Further fee cuts will likely discourage many doctors from continuing to participate in Medicare.