Most patients with heart conditions don't need to take antibiotics to reduce the risk of infection prior to a dental procedure, according to revised American Heart Association guidelines.
The previous recommendations advised that patients with any heart abnormality, from mild valve prolapse to severe birth defects, should take amoxicillin prior to a dental procedure to reduce the risk of developing infective endocarditis (IE). Many types of fungi and bacteria can cause the infection, and dental procedures had been seen as opening the door for these organisms to attack vulnerable patients.
But the guidelines writing group, led by Dr. Walter Wilson of the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn., reviewed the latest research and found no significant evidence that taking antibiotics before a dental procedure prevents IE in patients who are at risk for infections (Circulation 2007 May 8 [Epub doi:10.1161/circulationaha.106.183095]).
In addition, no prospective randomized, placebo-controlled studies have shown that antibiotic use prior to a dental procedure prevents IE. And daily activities such as toothbrushing and flossing cause transient bacteremia. (See story below.)
In fact, severe adverse events resulting from IE are associated with only a small subgroup of cardiac conditions, the writing group noted, and these patients should continue to receive antibiotics prior to dental procedures.
Patients who should receive antibiotics prior to dental procedures are those with prosthetic cardiac valves or previous episodes of infective endocarditis, and heart transplant patients with abnormal cardiac valves.
In addition, patients who meet the following criteria should receive antibiotics prior to dental procedures:
▸ Patients with repaired congenital heart disease (CHD) who have remaining defects at or near the site of a patch or prosthetic that inhibit the healing of the inner surfaces of the heart vessels.
▸ Patients with unrepaired cyanotic CHD, including those with palliative shunts or conduits.
▸ Patients with repaired CHD with no remaining defects who are within 6 months of the procedure (because the inner vessel surfaces are still healing).
Such patients should receive antibiotics prior to any dental procedure that involves work on the gums, the apex of the tooth, or perforation of oral mucosa. The guidelines apply to children as well as adults and have been endorsed by the Infectious Diseases Society of America, Pediatric Infectious Disease Society, and American Dental Association.
The previous guidelines, last revised in 1997, called for 2 g of amoxicillin to be given orally 1 hour before a procedure. But amoxicillin use carries risks of its own, including fostering the development of amoxicillin-resistant organisms, and data have not supported any reduced risk of IE as a result of prophylactic antibiotic use prior to dental procedures.
The new guidelines emphasize that antibiotic use should be based on the odds of a heart patient having a severe adverse reaction if he or she developed IE, rather than lumping all heart patients together as being at increased risk for IE.
“In fact, maintaining good oral health and hygiene appears to be more protective than prophylactic antibiotics,” Dr. Wilson said in a statement. Dr. Wilson had no financial disclosures related to his work on the guidelines.
Similarly, only cardiac patients who meet the above criteria need to receive antibiotics prior to respiratory tract, skin, or musculoskeletal procedures, according to the new guidelines.
Physicians might need to reassure patients with heart conditions other than the high-risk conditions specified in the guidelines that their risk for developing IE is low, and remind them that the ability of antibiotics to reduce the risk of IE is equally low, the writing group noted.