Commentary

Information blocking: Adolescent confidentiality is collateral damage


 

On April 4, 2021, a rule implementing the federal regulations of the Information Blocking 21st Century Cures Act will be enacted. This Act furthers the seamless release of medical records to promote improved outcomes, access to medical information, and transparency of costs. These regulations, although important, may impact the ability to offer confidentiality to adolescents seeking care for sensitive issues. Each state will need to be thoughtful balancing the action or inaction of allowing access to confidential or sensitive progress notes, as interference with access may be considered information blocking and subject to penalties and fines.

Gavel and stethoscope belchonock/Thinkstock

With adolescent confidential notes, protection rules may not apply under the information blocking regulations. These regulations will release progress notes, imaging narratives, procedure notes, and labs to parents via their EHR portals. The release of information is not limited, and both inpatient and outpatient records will be released. These regulations are written for adults with the assumption that all information is released to the individual receiving the care and shared with outside providers.

Ms. Margaret Thew, medical director of the department of adolescent medicine at Children's Wisconsin in Milwaukee

Ms. Margaret Thew

Unfortunately, the rules do not take into consideration adolescent confidential care. There are eight rules for the exception of releasing information, but it may be a stretch to place adolescent confidential progress notes under any of these eight exceptions. These exceptions are ambiguous and open to interpretation yet require specific documentation as to the limitation of access. Exceptions are prevention of harm; privacy conflicts; the security of the electronic health information; infeasibility, which includes challenges limiting the ability to comply; Health IT performance; content and manner; fees; and licensing.

Ms. Thew is medical director of the department of adolescent medicine at Children’s Wisconsin in Milwaukee. She is a member of the Pediatric News editorial advisory board. She had no relevant financial disclosures. Email Ms. Thew at pdnews@mdedge.com.

Recommended Reading

COVID spikes exacerbate health worker shortages in Rocky Mountains, Great Plains
MDedge Internal Medicine
Chinese American families suffer discrimination related to COVID-19
MDedge Internal Medicine
HHS extends deadline for patient access to your clinical notes
MDedge Internal Medicine
AMA reports a crash in physician revenues, visits over summer
MDedge Internal Medicine
Frivolous lawsuits: Still a big threat to doctors?
MDedge Internal Medicine
Health sector has spent $464 million on lobbying in 2020
MDedge Internal Medicine
Survey finds European dermatologists unhappy with pandemic teledermatology experience
MDedge Internal Medicine
Twelve medical groups pen letter opposing UHC copay accumulator program
MDedge Internal Medicine
Primary care journals address systemic racism in medicine
MDedge Internal Medicine
Primary care workforce expanding, but mostly in cities
MDedge Internal Medicine