Commentary

When patients demand vaccinated health care providers


 

Employer options

So, what can health care employers do? They have three options:

  • Require vaccination of all employees, independent contractors, and other providers who have privileges to see patients. Then, as long as the employer enforces the vaccination mandate, the employer can tell patients that all providers are vaccinated.
  • Not require that employees and others with access to patients be vaccinated, and if a patient requests to be seen only by vaccinated providers, provide that patient with a vaccinated provider. It is especially important that health care employers take care with patients who are unvaccinated and who have been advised not to be vaccinated because of a medical condition. Both the patient and the health care employer would be protected best by avoiding having two unvaccinated individuals interact. Masks and physical distancing may decrease the risk.
  • Not require that employees be vaccinated and refuse to guarantee that providers are vaccinated. To avoid risk for future lawsuits, employers should inform patients that there is no assurance that providers are vaccinated. That leaves it to each patient to ask individual providers about the provider’s vaccination status. If a patient doesn’t like a provider’s answer, then the patient has the right to leave. It’s not clear that the patient has a legal right to stay and demand a vaccinated provider.

Option three is problematic for a number of reasons. Patients aren’t always in a position to query each provider who enters the room about vaccination status. Patients may be sedated or too ill to exert that effort. And it puts supervisors in the position of having to mediate situations where a patient wants to leave against medical advice but the option of staying may also be dangerous.

Health care employers should discuss the options with their legal counsel before deciding which option to adopt.

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.

Pages

Recommended Reading

Delta variant key to breakthrough infections in vaccinated Israelis
MDedge Internal Medicine
Fitbit stats show lingering physiologic hit after COVID-19
MDedge Internal Medicine
‘Long haul’ COVID recovery worse than cancer rehab for some: CDC
MDedge Internal Medicine
FDA to warn J&J that vaccine can increase Guillain-Barré risk: Media
MDedge Internal Medicine
Patients on methotrexate show T-cell response to Pfizer vaccine
MDedge Internal Medicine
Do patients with cancer need a third shot of COVID vaccine?
MDedge Internal Medicine
Delta variant infects six vaccinated guests at outdoor wedding
MDedge Internal Medicine
Vaccine mandates, passports, and Kant
MDedge Internal Medicine
Health anxiety common as COVID restrictions loosen
MDedge Internal Medicine
Early heparin treatment linked to lower COVID-19 mortality
MDedge Internal Medicine