U.S. in worse shape
In a comment, Christopher Calandrella, DO, chair of emergency medicine at Long Island Jewish Forest Hills,, New York, part of Northwell Health, said: “Significant data are available to support the importance of prompt initiation of CPR and defibrillation for OHCA, and although this study did not demonstrate a meaningful increase in use of AEDs with the trial system, layperson CPR was initiated in approximately 70% of cases in the cohort as a whole. Because of this, I believe it is evident that patients still benefit from a system that encourages bystanders to provide aid prior to the arrival of EMS.”
Nevertheless, he noted, “despite the training of volunteers in applying an AED, overall, only a small percentage of patients in either group had placement and use of the device. While the reasons likely are multifactorial, it may be in part due to the significant stress and anxiety associated with OHCA.”
Additional research would be helpful, he said. “Future studies focusing on more rural areas with lower population density and limited availability of AEDs may be beneficial. Expanding the research outside of Europe to other countries would be useful. Next-phase trials looking at 30-day survival in these patients would also be important.”
Currently in the United States, research is underway to evaluate the use of smartphones to improve in-hospital cardiac arrests, he added, “but no nationwide programs are in place for OHCA.”
Similarly, Kevin G. Volpp, MD, PhD, and Benjamin S. Abella, MD, MPhil, both of the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, wrote in a related editorial: “It is sobering to recognize that, in the U.S., it may be nearly impossible to even test an idea like this, given the lack of a supporting data infrastructure.”
Although there is an app in the United States to link OHCA events to bystander response, they noted, less than half of eligible 911 centers have linked to it.
“Furthermore, the bystander CPR rate in the U.S. is less than 35%, only about half of the Swedish rate, indicating far fewer people are trained in CPR and comfortable performing it in the U.S.,” they wrote. “A wealthy country like the U.S. should be able to develop a far more effective approach to preventing millions of ... families from having a loved one die of OHCA in the decade to come.”
The study was funded by unrestricted grant from the Swedish Heart-Lung Foundation and Stockholm County. The authors, editorialists, and Dr. Calandrella disclosed no relevant financial relationships.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.