Conference Coverage

Meditation curbs stress, depression as adjunct to CAD rehab


 

FROM ESC PREVENTIVE CARDIOLOGY 2023

Regular meditation reduced depression by roughly 44% in adults with coronary artery disease who were involved in a cardiovascular rehabilitation program.

An increasing body of research supports the impact of psychological risk factors including stress, personality type, anger, and hostility on conditions such as depression and anxiety, but also social isolation and low socioeconomic status, Ana Luisa Vitorino Monteiro, MD, of the University of Lisbon said in a presentation at the annual congress of the European Association of Preventive Cardiology. In addition, “stress, anxiety, and depression deteriorate the cardiovascular (CV) system through psycho-neuro-immunoendocrinology system and behavioral pathways.”

Meditation as a tool for stress management has been gaining popularity, but its use as part of a CV rehabilitation program as a complementary therapy has not been well studied, she added.

Dr. Monteiro and colleagues recruited 80 adults with CAD who were undergoing CV rehabilitation to join a meditation program. Of these, 48 accepted (60%) and 40% declined. Those who accepted were part of an exercise-based CV rehabilitation program that met three times a week for at least 6 months. The mean age of the participants was 65 years, and 80% were male.

Participants were randomized to an intervention group with a weekly 90-minute session that included breathing and meditation for 1 month in addition to usual care, or to usual care in the rehabilitation program. Over the next 3 months, the intervention patients were encouraged to practice daily meditation for 20 minutes alone or using video support material, with a weekly follow-up phone call. Assessments of stress, anxiety, and depression took place at baseline and after 4 months using the Perceived Stress Scale, Beck Anxiety Inventory, Beck Depression Inventory, and HeartQoL questionnaire.

At 4 months, individuals in the meditation group had reduced depression levels significantly, by 44%, compared with controls (P < .001). Anxiety and stress decreased significantly, by 30% (P = .04) and 31% (P = .05), respectively. After 4 months, individuals in the control group were offered the opportunity to follow the meditation protocol.

In addition, “the emotional dimension of quality of life increased by 60% in the intervention group,” Dr. Monteiro noted. However, physical QoL did not change between groups.

The study was limited by the small sample size, and more research is needed in larger and more diverse populations, Dr. Monteiro said. However, the results support the value of meditation as an adjunct component of care for CAD patients in a long-term rehabilitation program.

Motivation makes a difference

The current study is important as an exploration of “a straightforward, simple, low-risk approach that could be an adjunct to benefit patients with serious cardiovascular disease,” Brian Olshansky, MD, a cardiologist at the University of Iowa, Iowa City, said in an interview.

Dr. Brian Olshansky, emeritus professor of internal medicine-cardiovascular medicine at the University of Iowa Carver College of Medicine, Iowa City

Dr. Brian Olshansky

“We have moved into a time of polypharmacy and multiple interventions for patients with underlying cardiovascular disease which, in many cases, have proven benefit but also potential adverse effects,” he said. “Engaging patients to participate in their health care, when there is serious underlying cardiovascular disease, has potential beneficial impact in many ways. Meditation is a low-risk, low-cost, potentially beneficial adjunct to standard medical therapy that may enhance psychological outcomes as shown here in this small study.”

However, “patients often rely on high-cost, potentially high-risk therapeutic interventions, expecting complete control of their problems without their own collaborative intervention,” he noted.

Dr. Olshansky said he was not surprised by any of the findings, and would have been surprised if meditation had failed to show any benefit for the study population.

“I am very pleased to see these results and would encourage meditation practice to be part of cardiovascular rehabilitation for motivated individuals,” he said. “What did surprise me was the adherence to the meditation protocol for those who participated. This represents a highly motivated group and it may be difficult to expect the same results in less motivated individuals.”

The current study has several strengths, including the use of controls and high rates of adherence to the protocol, said Dr. Olshansky. Other strengths include the standardized approach and the reasonable quality of the outcome measures, which showed a substantial benefit.

However, “this is a small study of motivated individuals of whom 80% were male,” and generalizability to other populations is unclear, Dr. Olshansky said. In addition, the racial mix was not described, and the severity of the underlying coronary artery disease and the therapies provided to these individuals is not detailed. A sicker population may not fare as well.”

The reasons for the benefits of meditation remain uncertain, Dr. Olshansky said. “It could be, specifically, that the meditation itself has physiological effects that ultimately translate into psychosocial benefit. However, those who enrolled and were interested may have derived a placebo effect. In any case, benefit was achieved, but the crossover benefit to the control group is unclear.

“In other words, the statistical approach to benefit is uncertain as to when it was measured, but presumably before the control group was allowed to engage in a meditation practice,” and the follow-up was short term, said Dr. Olshansky.

Data support patient engagement

The message to clinicians and patients: “Patients should be engaged in their own health care when it comes to rehabilitation for cardiovascular disease,” said Dr. Olshansky. “Motivated individuals who are educated about a meditative practice performed in a standardized way will have improvement most likely in their quality of life, and when it comes to measurements of depression, stress and anxiety.”

Although the mechanisms behind the benefits remain unclear, “having a standardized credible prescription for which patients can become intimately engaged is beneficial,” he added.

The study received no outside funding. Neither Dr. Monteiro nor Dr. Olshansky had any financial conflicts to disclose.

Recommended Reading

Disparities in statin use persist in high-risk Americans
MDedge Internal Medicine
One or two high-step days may reduce mortality risks
MDedge Internal Medicine
Subclinical CAD by CT predicts MI risk, with or without stenoses
MDedge Internal Medicine
Some diets better than others for heart protection
MDedge Internal Medicine
High salt intake linked to atherosclerosis even with normal BP
MDedge Internal Medicine
Statins don’t worsen muscle injury from moderately intense exercise
MDedge Internal Medicine
Antiphospholipid antibodies linked to future CV events
MDedge Internal Medicine
AHA statement targets nuance in CVD risk assessment of women
MDedge Internal Medicine
Cardiovascular disease deaths rise on and after high-pollution days
MDedge Internal Medicine
Green Mediterranean diet may relieve aortic stiffness
MDedge Internal Medicine