From the Journals

Low-carb, plant-rich diets tied to breast cancer survival?


 

TOPLINE:

A new analysis shows a significant association between plant-rich, low-carbohydrate diets and overall survival, but not breast cancer–specific survival, among women with stage I-III breast cancer.

METHODOLOGY:

  • The diets of 9,621 women with stage I-III breast cancer from two ongoing cohort studies – the Nurses’ Health Study and Nurses’ Health Study II – were evaluated.
  • Overall low-carb, animal-rich, and plant-rich low-carb diet scores were calculated using food frequency questionnaires after breast cancer diagnosis.
  • Cox proportional hazards regression models adjusted for multiple potential confounding factors.
  • Follow-up lasted for a median of 12.4 years after breast cancer diagnosis.

TAKEAWAY:

  • Overall, 1,269 deaths due to breast cancer and 3,850 all-cause deaths occurred during the follow-up period.
  • Researchers found that greater adherence to low-carb (hazard ratio, 0.82 for quintile 5 vs. 1) and plant-rich diet (HR, 0.73 Q5 vs. 1) was associated with a significantly lower risk for overall mortality but not breast cancer–specific mortality.
  • Overall, adhering to animal-rich, low-carb diets did not significantly influence all-cause or breast cancer–specific survival rates.
  • But replacing 3% of energy intake from available carbohydrates with fish protein was associated with 17% lower risk for breast cancer–specific mortality and 15% lower risk for all-cause mortality.

IN PRACTICE:

“The findings suggest that breast cancer survivors could benefit from limiting intake of carbohydrates, especially from fruit juice, sugar-sweetened beverages, and added sugar, and increasing the amount of protein and fat, in particular from plant sources,” the authors write.

STUDY DETAILS:

The study was led by Maryam Farvid, PhD, with the Data Statistics Group, Mission Viejo, Calif. It was published online in the journal Cancer and supported by National Institutes of Health and the University of Toronto.

LIMITATIONS:

Most women were non-Hispanic White and health professionals, so the results might not generalize to other sociodemographic groups. The authors also noted potential residual confounding, despite controlling for several breast cancer risk factors.

DISCLOSURES:

Dr. Farvid is a founder of the Institute for Cancer Prevention and Healing and the Data Statistics Group.

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.

Recommended Reading

BMI has greater impact on survival in younger breast cancer patients
MDedge Internal Medicine
Risk for breast cancer reduced after bariatric surgery
MDedge Internal Medicine
Atezolizumab is associated with enhanced response in triple-negative breast cancer
MDedge Internal Medicine
Genomic assay changes minds on HER2+ BC treatment
MDedge Internal Medicine
Breast cancer survivors need a comprehensive care plan, says doctor
MDedge Internal Medicine
Breast cancer outcomes are worse for Black men
MDedge Internal Medicine
Circulating tumor DNA may predict poor prognosis in breast cancer
MDedge Internal Medicine
Lack of paid sick leave is a barrier to cancer screening
MDedge Internal Medicine
Breast cancer: Meta-analysis supports ovarian suppression/ablation
MDedge Internal Medicine
Phone support helps weight loss in patients with breast cancer
MDedge Internal Medicine