Intriguing, sobering
In an accompanying editorial, Bertha Madras, PhD, McLean Hospital, Belmont, Mass., and Harvard Medical School, Boston, noted “the findings are both intriguing and sobering. The highest dose (25 mg), but not the intermediate dose (10 mg), resulted in significantly lower levels of depressive symptoms after 3 weeks than the lowest dose (1 mg, which served as a control), but the 37% incidence of response with the 25-mg dose was numerically lower than that in large trials of conventional antidepressants and less robust than in a trial showing similar efficacies of psilocybin and a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor.”
Also sobering, she noted, were the high percentages of adverse events in the 25-mg group and suicidal ideation and behavior. Dr. Madras also wondered if “legalization and commercialization [of psychedelics] are allied with the medical movement, psychedelic shops and ‘clinics’ could proliferate even for vulnerable populations, and rigorously designed medical protocols will be compromised.
“Nevertheless,” she concluded, “it is provocative that these agents show some short-term benefit for depression in selected populations.”
Dr. Goodwin is CMO of Compass Pathways, which funded the study. He and several coauthors disclosed relationships with industry. Dr. Madras reports no relevant financial relationships.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.