SEATTLE – Failed in-vitro fertilization (IVF) treatment appears to boost the risk of relapse in women with multiple sclerosis (MS). Does successful IVF have the same effect? The preliminary results of a new study suggests it does, a finding that may influence how physicians track patients during pregnancy.
“We found that IVF can still cause a relapse even if it is successful,” study lead author Maria Claudia Manieri, a graduate student at Harvard Medical School’s Partners MS Center, said in an interview at the annual meeting of the Consortium of Multiple Sclerosis Centers, where she presented the findings.
Multiple studies have linked infertility treatment in women with MS to relapses. In a 2013 review, researchers analyzed several papers, and “all of them reported an increase in annualized relapse rate after ART [assisted reproductive treatment]. Furthermore, in a recent study, clinical worsening was associated with an increase in MRI activity” (Clin Immunol. 2013 Nov;149(2):219-24).
For the new report, based on statistics from the New England Multiple Sclerosis Pregnancy Prospective Cohort Study, Ms. Manieri and colleagues collected data on 91 women (mean age = 33). Eleven were unsuccessful in conceiving, and 80 successfully conceived.
Three of the 91 women (3%) used intrauterine insemination as a fertility treatment. Another 9 (10%) relied on ART; all used IVF except for 1 who underwent intracytoplasmic sperm injection.
The new report is a preliminary analysis of early data, Ms. Manieri said. The study has recruited about one-sixth of its participants, she said, and will track women beyond pregnancy to explore long-term outcomes in their children.
Eleven women relapsed during pregnancy, including 9 who were using fertility treatment (P = .003). Of those 9, 7 women (78%) used ART.
No other factor other than fertility treatment predicted intrapartum relapses. The relapses during pregnancy started at 21 weeks (± 12 weeks) of gestational age and lasted for 4 weeks (± 2 weeks).
Of those who successfully conceived, 4 of 5 (80%) who used fertility treatment relapsed, compared with 7 of 64 (11%) who didn’t use fertility treatment. Of women who did not successfully conceive, 2 of 3 (67%) relapsed among those who used fertility treatment vs. 1 of 7 (14%) of those who didn’t.
It’s not clear how infertility treatment may be boosting MS relapse in women, but the 2013 review offered these possibilities: “temporary interruption of disease modified therapies, stressful events associated with infertility, and immunological changes induced by hormones such as increase in pro-inflammatory cytokines and anti-MOG antibodies, as well as an increase in immune cell migration across the blood-brain-barrier.”
MS tends to improve during pregnancy, and it’s common for neurologists to not see patients for extended periods, Ms. Manieri said. In light of the findings, she said, it may be wise for neurologists to continue follow-up appointments during pregnancy. “Avoid delaying care and keep monitoring the patient,” she advised.
The study was funded by Sanofi Genzyme and a gift from Michelle and Christopher Rondeau. The study authors report no relevant disclosures.