PHYSICIAN LEADERSHIP: RACIAL DISPARITIES AND RACISM. WHERE DO WE GO FROM HERE?
BIFTU MENGESHA, MD, MAS; KAVITA SHAH ARORA, MD, MBE, MS; AND BARBARA LEVY, MD
(COMMENTARY; AUGUST 2020)
Political diatribe paints a huge swath
I read the above referenced article with equal measure of angst and offense, amazement and incredulity, irritation and, some would say, typical white male denial. The authors have succumbed to the zeitgeist currently enveloping our country and painted us all with one huge swath of the same proverbial brush—inappropriately.
No doubt certain reforms are needed in our society and perhaps within areas of medicine. I am for anything that improves all peoples’ lives and health. The country is rightfully clamoring for equality. That means equality for all, however. But by way of one small example of systemic overreaction, many articles now are replete with comments about “Black people and Brown people and white people.” Adjectives have been turned into proper nouns, but applied only to some groups, not all. That foments continued inequity, not equality.
The authors implore us to strive for “engaged, passionate, and innovative leadership deliberately aimed toward antiracism and equity.” In my view, the best way I can do that is not by words but actions, and that is to do what I am trained to do, which is take care of patients the best I can regardless of their color or creed. I have always done that, and everyone I work with does as well. For the authors to imply I (we) don’t is at a minimum offensive and pejorative, and flat wrong.
I agree to a certain extent that our health care contributes to poor, or at least less desirable, outcomes. But so do the actions or inactions of our patients. I do not agree that it is a racial issue. It affects all people. I see it every day. I am probably in the minority of physicians who think we should go to a single-payor system (note I did not say free). But to state that the system creates poor outcomes only for “Blacks, Indigenous, and Latinx,” I disagree. Tennessee has TennCare (Medicaid) and almost anyone can get it, and if they are pregnant they certainly can. Access is not an issue. All people have to do is avail themselves of it. It does not matter the race!
The authors call for the implementation “of system-wide intersectional and antiracist practices” to address “racism, sexism, gender discrimination, economic and social injustice.” They are preaching to the wrong crowd. If I (we) pursued all these lofty goals, I (we) would not have time to care for the very patients they are now lamenting don’t have enough care or proper care.
I facilitate conversations on a regular basis with my black patients as well as my white patients. I recently asked a patient if she distrusted me because I am a white male. It is enlightening to hear patient comments, which are mostly along the lines of “the world has gone crazy.” That is a polite interpretation of their comments. Maybe they say what they think I want to hear, but I don’t think so.
“Repair what we have broken…” by “uplifting their voices and redistributing our power to them.” I don’t see how I (we) have broken anything. If taking care of all comers as best as one can has broken something, then I am guilty. Regarding that I need to examine how “we have eroded the trust of the very communities we care for” and that we are guilty of “medical experimentation on and exploitation of Black and Brown bodies,” what are we to examine? How have I (we) eroded the trust? Present-day physicians had nothing to do with things like the Tuskegee Institute experiment, and I hardly see how blaming us today for that abominable episode in our HISTORY is a valid point. Implying that we add to that distrust by not giving the same pain relief to certain people because of race is just preposterous. Further, asking to let others lead, for example, on the medical executive committee or in positions such as chief of service or chief of staff usually are not something one “gets” to be, but something one usually is “talked into.” There is not a racial barrier to those roles, at least at my institution, and once again the brush has inappropriately painted us all.
I understand the general gestalt of this article and agree with its basic premises. But while well meaning, this political diatribe belongs in the halls of Congress, not in the halls of our hospitals or the pages of a medical journal. I am tired of being told, directly or indirectly, that I am a racist by TV news, newspapers, social media, professional sports teams, and now by my medical journals. I would ask the authors to be careful who they throw under the bus.
Scott Peters, MD
Oak Ridge, Tennessee
Continue to: Drs. Mengesha, Arora, and Levy respond...