Medical Verdicts

Failure to place cerclage blamed for brain damage


 

Undisclosed County (Mass) Superior Court

Due to an incompetent cervix, a woman gave birth at 25 weeks’ gestation to a baby girl. The child suffered severe brain damage as a result of her prematurity.

In suing, the mother claimed that the Ob/Gyn failed to recommend cervical cerclage despite the fact that the woman had a prior fetal loss due to an incompetent cervix, as well as a previous successful pregnancy with the placement of a prophylactic cerclage. The woman maintained that her child’s injuries would have been avoided had a cerclage been utilized.

The Ob/Gyn contended that the patient’s medical history as described was not consistent with an incompetent cervix. The physician maintained that treatment as provided fell within the standard of care.

  • The case settled for $2.6 million.
The cases presented here were compiled by Lewis L. Laska, editor of Medical Malpractice Verdicts, Settlements & Experts. While there are instances when the available information is incomplete, these cases represent the types of clinical situations that typically result in litigation.

Recommended Reading

Decoding the codes: How to apply the new ICD-9
MDedge ObGyn
Incorrect intubation results in brain damage
MDedge ObGyn
Did failure to note fetal distress cause hypoxia, brain damage?
MDedge ObGyn
Woman without breast cancer undergoes mastectomy
MDedge ObGyn
IUD left in patient after hysterectomy
MDedge ObGyn
Was hysterectomy needed for borderline ovarian tumor?
MDedge ObGyn
Was terminal breast cancer a result of late diagnosis?
MDedge ObGyn
Blind amniocentesis leads to 19 punctures, fetal demise
MDedge ObGyn
Fetal death follows twin-to-twin transfusion
MDedge ObGyn
Athetoid quadriplegia, deafness follow bloody discharge in newborn
MDedge ObGyn