Practice Economics

Obama gets do-over in ACA subsidy lawsuit


 

References

The Obama administration is getting a second chance to show that providing tax subsidies through the Affordable Care Act’s federally run insurance marketplace is legal.

On Sept. 4, the District of Columbia Circuit of the U.S. Court of Appeals granted the government’s petition for a rehearing en banc in Halbig v. Burwell. The rehearing will be heard by all 17 judges on the court and the previous ruling made by a three-judge panel of the court has been vacated.

©BanksPhotos/iStockphoto

Hope remains for those supporting the legality of tax subsidies handed down by Obamacare.

The earlier ruling, issued on July 22, was 2-1 in favor of the plaintiffs and, had it been upheld, had the potential to strip insurance subsidies from about 5 million Americans who had purchased health plans through the federally run marketplace.

Also on July 22, the 4th Circuit of the U.S. Court of Appeals in Virginia handed down a conflicting ruling, siding unanimously with the government in a similar case, King v. Burwell. The King plaintiffs have already appealed to the Supreme Court, but the high court has not indicated whether it will consider the case.

At issue is whether the federal government has the authority to issue tax subsidies to consumers from 36 states who purchase insurance on the federal marketplace since the ACA specifies only that subsidies would be available on the state-run marketplaces. The plaintiffs have argued that the administration is overstepping its authority by also offering subsidies on the federal marketplace. But administration officials maintain that Congress intended the subsidies to be offered to all eligible consumers regardless of who operates the marketplace.

The D.C. appellate court will hear oral arguments in Halbig v. Burwell on Dec. 17.

mschneider@frontlinemedcom.com

On Twitter @maryellenny

Recommended Reading

VIDEO: Federal health IT chief DeSalvo talks meaningful use
MDedge ObGyn
Physicians in group practice setting make more
MDedge ObGyn
CMS extends Open Payment review and dispute deadline – again
MDedge ObGyn
Blood test charges vary widely among California hospitals
MDedge ObGyn
CMS finalizes ‘flexibility’ in EHR meaningful use program
MDedge ObGyn
CMS finalizes marketplace autoenrollment rule
MDedge ObGyn
Smokers not so welcome in the house anymore
MDedge ObGyn
Meaningful use – Stage 2 (Part 1 of 2)
MDedge ObGyn
Patient-centered medical home shows cost savings potential
MDedge ObGyn
Health spending growth still low, but expected to speed up over next decade
MDedge ObGyn

Related Articles