Behavioral Consult

Psychotherapy


 

The term “psychotherapy” describes a variety of talk-based treatments for psychiatric illnesses. Its fundamental premise is that there are determinants of mood, anxiety, and behavior that are not fully in our conscious awareness. By becoming more aware or by developing skills in managing thoughts and feelings, patients can get relief from symptoms that often impair functioning. The focus on unconscious thoughts, feelings, and behaviors is the central principle of dynamic psychotherapy in which the therapist listens to the patients speak freely about important people and events in their day-to-day lives and takes note of themes that emerge. Eventually they offer “interpretations” to their patients about these patterns, and ways that current problems may connect to powerful experiences from their earlier lives.

Dynamic psychotherapy is often contrasted with supportive psychotherapy. This is not cheerleading, but instead refers to supporting the healthy ability to think about oneself, one’s thoughts and emotions, and one’s needs, and the tension that these can create with the expectations of society. In working with children and adolescents, therapists are almost always supporting the age-appropriate development of some of these skills, particularly if a child has gotten developmentally stuck because of depressive, anxious, or attentional symptoms. There are almost always supportive elements in psychotherapy with a school-age or teenage child.

Dr. Susan D. Swick

Dr. Susan D. Swick

For children with anxiety disorders or mild to moderate depression, cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) is an evidence-based first-line treatment. CBT is a structured psychotherapy that helps patients to identify specific thoughts that trigger or follow their mood or anxiety symptoms, and then sets about establishing new (less-distorted) thoughts or practicing avoided behaviors to help learn new responses. It appears to be especially effective for anxiety disorders (such as social phobia, panic disorder, and generalized anxiety disorder) and for obsessive-compulsive disorder. There are specialized types of CBT that can be offered to patients (including children) who have been exposed to trauma and even for teenagers experiencing psychotic symptoms. It should be noted that one of the reasons that CBT has a robust evidence base supporting its use is that it is one of the most structured types of psychotherapy. It is standardized, reproducible, and easier to study than most other varieties of psychotherapy. Practicing CBT requires specific training, so in looking for a CBT therapist, one needs to ask whether she is CBT trained, and even whether she is trained in the type of CBT specific for the disorder you are treating.

A relative of CBT is dialectical behavioral therapy or DBT, developed to treat borderline personality disorder, a maladaptive pattern of identity uncertainty, emotional instability, and impulsivity that often starts in adolescence, causing stormy relationships and poor self-regulation that can contribute to self-injury, substance abuse, and chronic suicidality. DBT focuses on cognitive patterns, and utilizes a patient’s strengths to build new skills at managing challenging thoughts and feelings. The “dialectic” relates to interpersonal relationships, as this is where these patients often have great difficulty. High-quality DBT is often done with both individual and group therapy sessions. There is substantial evidence supporting the efficacy of this therapy in patients with borderline personality disorder.

Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Play therapy generally refers to the use of play (with toys, dolls, art, or games) in therapy with the youngest children. Such young children are unlikely to speak in a fluid manner about their relationships or struggles, as they may lack some of the cognitive means to be self-reflective. So instead, a therapist will watch for themes in their play (aggression, cheating, repetitive stories with dolls or art) that may reflect important themes, that they will then work on in play or in speaking, as tolerated. Therapists of older children also may use play to help these children feel more comfortable as they proceed with CBT or another talk therapy.

While gathering data from parents is always part of therapy for children, family therapy brings the whole family into a room with the therapist, who focuses on the roles each person may play in the family and patterns of communication (verbal and otherwise) that may be contributing to a young person’s symptoms. Family therapy can be very important in treating anorexia nervosa, somatoform illnesses, and conduct disorder in children and adolescents. While it can be a complex type of therapy to study, there is significant evidence supporting its efficacy in these very challenging disorders of youth.

There is a growing body of evidence in adults demonstrating neuroimaging changes after effective psychotherapies. Several studies of patients with OCD who were successfully treated with CBT have demonstrated decreased metabolism in the right caudate nucleus, and those treated effectively for phobias showed decreased activity in the limbic and paralimbic areas. Interestingly, patients with OCD and phobias who were effectively treated with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors demonstrated these same changes on functional neuroimaging (Mol Psychiatry. 2006 Jun;11[6]:528-38.). An Italian meta-analysis of patients treated for major depression with medications (usually selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors) or with psychotherapy (usually CBT) demonstrated different, and possibly complementary brain changes in the two treatment groups (Brain Imaging Behav. 2015 Jul 12. [Epub ahead of print]). With time, these studies may help us to better understand the nature of specific illnesses and more about neuroplasticity, and may even help us to understand when medications, therapy, or both are indicated.

Pages

Recommended Reading

Chronic illness associated with lower developmental readiness for school entry
MDedge Pediatrics
Bill in Calif. seeks to ameliorate problem of finding scarce psychiatric hospital beds
MDedge Pediatrics
Bill in Calif. seeks to ameliorate problem of finding scarce psychiatric hospital beds
MDedge Pediatrics
CDC confirms Zika virus as a cause of microcephaly
MDedge Pediatrics
Standardized policies reduce health care utilization for neonatal abstinence syndrome
MDedge Pediatrics
Cognitive behavioral therapy alternative helps depressed teens
MDedge Pediatrics
Single-question screen for alcohol use disorder good for rural teens
MDedge Pediatrics
HHS urged to lead efforts to destigmatize mental, behavioral disorders
MDedge Pediatrics
Heavy marijuana use by male adolescents tied to higher mortality risk
MDedge Pediatrics
Sharing the lanes
MDedge Pediatrics