News

LAIV no better than IIV for influenza protection in children


 

FROM ANNALS OF INTERNAL MEDICINE

References

Live attenuated influenza vaccine (LAIV) was no more effective than inactivated influenza vaccine (IIV) in small, compact, rural communities, according to Mark Loeb, MD, and his associates.

For the study, vaccinations were given to children aged 36 months to 15 years living in Hutterite colonies in Canada. Hutterite colonies are isolated, their residents live communally, and influenza is prevalent, making them suited for this cluster randomized trial.

Of the 1,186 children included in the study, mean coverage was 76.7% in the LAIV group, compared with 72.4% in the IIV group. Incidence of influenza was 5.3% in the LAIV group and 5.2% in the IIV group. Compared to IIV, the hazard ratio for LAIV for influenza A or B was 1.03.

Children vaccinated with LAIV were at a higher risk for influenza A (hazard ratio, 1.62), but were at lower risk for influenza B (HR, 0.66). Influenza attack rates were similar in children younger and older than 6 years old. Adverse reactions were more likely in the IIV group than in the LAIV group, but no serious adverse events were reported.

“Although influenza transmission networks in Hutterite communities may differ from that in other communities, there are no data to confirm this. In fact, there may be more variability in social networks between urban and rural communities – or even among various urban communities – than between Hutterite and other (rural) communities. Even if variability exists, if a clear benefit of LAIV over IIV in reducing influenza-associated illness cannot be detected in this setting it is unlikely to be seen in other communities,” the investigators noted.

Find the full study in Annals of Internal Medicine (doi: 10.7326/M16-0513).

lfranki@frontlinemedcom.com

Recommended Reading

Motivational interviewing for HPV vaccination well accepted by doctors
MDedge Pediatrics
Coadministering a combined MMRV vaccine with MenC vaccine is immunogenic
MDedge Pediatrics
Influenza: A vaccine we love to hate
MDedge Pediatrics
Approximately 9 million U.S. children, teens are vulnerable to measles infection
MDedge Pediatrics
Zika virus RNA detected in serum beyond previously estimated time frame
MDedge Pediatrics
Combo MenC vaccine loses effectiveness after 5 years
MDedge Pediatrics
Extended pneumococcal vaccination schedule boosts early immunity for preemies
MDedge Pediatrics
HPV vaccination provides protection for immunocompromised children
MDedge Pediatrics
Two-dose HPV vaccines at younger age are noninferior to standard three-dose vaccine
MDedge Pediatrics
NIAID to test new yellow fever vaccine
MDedge Pediatrics