Conference Coverage

Pediatricians report low knowledge, comfort discussing e-cigarettes


 

REPORTING FROM PAS 2019

Pediatricians appear less comfortable discussing e-cigarettes and their harms with adolescents and parents than they do discussing dangers of tobacco products, according to a recent study.

LiudmylaSupynska/Thinkstock

“Providers are aware of the increased prevalence, harms [of e-cigs] and [the] positive impact of counseling teens about e-cigs,” said Allison Heinly, MD, of Hasbro Children’s Hospital in Providence, R.I., and her colleagues. But, “providers are less likely to ask, advise, or assist parents [and teens] regarding e-cig use, compared to tobacco, and are less comfortable doing so.” The researchers presented their findings at the Pediatric Academic Societies annual meeting.

A variety of concerns exist regarding ingredients in e-cigarettes, Dr. Heinly noted, including nicotine, volatile organic compounds, carcinogenic chemicals, flavorings, and ultra-fine particles.

Dr. Heinly and her associates aimed to assess pediatricians’ knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors toward both teens’ and parents’ use of e-cigarettes, as well as the barrier pediatricians perceived when it came to screening and counseling those who use e-cigarettes.

Among 69 providers at a large Northeastern urban academic primary care clinic who received surveys, 62 responded, primarily residents (84%). The respondents included 44 pediatric residents, eight triple-board residents, and 10 attending physicians.

The researchers collapsed “most of the time”/“always” and “some of the time”/“never” responses into two categories.

Most of the respondents (82%) knew e-cigarettes are the most common tobacco product that youth use, and nearly all (97%) believed e-cigarettes were addictive and harmful to users’ health. In addition, most (79%) believed using e-cigarettes could be a pathway toward students beginning to use other drugs.

Even though respondents believed counseling teens about use of tobacco or e-cigarettes can reduce the likelihood that they will start using them, providers were much less likely to discuss e-cigarettes than tobacco with teens.

Nearly all the doctors (97%) reported asking teens about their use of tobacco, but only about half (52%) asked about e-cigarette use (P less than .001). And only about one in five doctors (21%) reported counseling teens about using e-cigarettes, compared with 47% of those who advised teens regarding tobacco use (P = .002).

Over a third of responding physicians (37%) reported helping adolescent patients quit using tobacco, but just 7% reported doing so with e-cigarettes (P less than .001).

Doctors overwhelmingly reported feeling comfortable talking about tobacco with teens (98%), but fewer felt comfortable discussing e-cigarettes (77%; P less than .001). Respondents similarly were less comfortable discussing e-cigarettes (55%) than tobacco (87%) with parents (P less than .001).

Very few pediatricians asked parents about their use of e-cigarettes (5%) or advised them about e-cigarettes’ harms (7%), and even fewer reported helping parents quit using them (2%). By contrast, more than half of pediatricians (60%) asked parents about smoking or advised them about tobacco use harms (52%), and nearly one-third (31%) reported helping parents quit smoking (P less than .001 for all comparisons).

The biggest barrier to discussing e-cigarettes with families was, as with discussing tobacco, not having enough time. But about twice as many respondents cited insufficient knowledge as a barrier for e-cigarettes as for tobacco (P = .003). A small percentage of respondents (less than 20%) also reported feeling unsure about the harm of e-cigarettes (P = .001).

Lack of training was a significant barrier to physicians’ discussion of e-cigarettes as well. Many more physicians reported receiving training in medical school on tobacco and traditional cigarettes (78%) than on e-cigarettes (13%), possibly because of how recently e-cigarettes have become widely available (P less than .001).

More physicians reported receiving training related to e-cigarettes during residency (36%), but it still fell well short of how many reported other tobacco and smoking training during residency (61%; P = .001).

The findings “emphasize the importance of increasing training about e-cig counseling,” Dr. Heinly and her associates concluded.

The researchers noted no external funding or disclosures.

Recommended Reading

Connected care
MDedge Pediatrics
House committee debates single-payer health care design
MDedge Pediatrics
Trump administration plans to repeal transgender health care protections
MDedge Pediatrics
Supreme Court upholds part of Indiana abortion law
MDedge Pediatrics
Guidelines recommend adding trained personnel for pediatric sedation during dental procedures
MDedge Pediatrics
Louisiana House passes 6-week abortion ban
MDedge Pediatrics
Patient-centered care in clinic
MDedge Pediatrics
Legal duty to nonpatients: Communicable diseases
MDedge Pediatrics
A longing for belonging
MDedge Pediatrics
Cannabis: Doctors tell FDA to get out of the weeds
MDedge Pediatrics