Universal screening for presymptomatic type 1 diabetes among schoolchildren would cost approximately 22 euros (about $25) per child screened, and about 7,000 euros (about $7,900) per child diagnosed, a new analysis of data from a German program finds.
The data come from the Fr1da study, in which a blood test for type 1 diabetes–associated islet autoantibodies is offered to all children aged 21 months to 6 years old in Bavaria.
Families of those who test positive are offered participation in a program of diabetes education, metabolic staging, psychological evaluation for stress, and prospective follow-up.
The researchers explain that, worldwide, 4 in 1,000 people under the age of 20 years have type 1 diabetes. It is the most common metabolic disease in children and adolescents. Only about 1 in 10 of those affected has a close relative with the disease. This means that type 1 diabetes can affect any child.
However, in many cases, the disease does not become known until a severe to life-threatening metabolic derailment known as diabetic ketoacidosis (DKA) occurs. This often leads to intensive medical treatment, a longer hospitalization, and poorer blood glucose control, which can result in an increased risk of secondary diseases and very high costs for the health care system.
“We want to protect as many children as possible from serious metabolic derailments. This is only possible with type 1 diabetes screenings. Therefore, we strongly support to include early detection tests in standard medical care,” Peter Achenbach, DrMed, senior author of the study, said in a statement from his institution, Helmholtz Zentrum München in Neuherberg, Germany.
The new findings were published in Diabetes Care by Florian M. Karl, also of Helmholtz Zentrum München, and colleagues.
In 2020, the Fr1da investigators reported that, of 90,632 children who participated from February 2015 to May 2019, 0.31% (280) were diagnosed with presymptomatic type 1 diabetes through the presence of two or more islet autoantibodies.
This news organization asked Brett McQueen, PhD, who led a similar study examining cost and cost-effectiveness in the Autoimmunity Screening for Kids (ASK) program, in which Denver-area children aged 2-17 years are offered autoantibody screening for both type 1 diabetes and celiac disease, for comment.
“If we have a chance to change a child’s life from when they’re 2 or 3 years old and there’s even a small chance that this thing potentially improves health outcomes for a decent price, what are we waiting for?” said Dr. McQueen, who is assistant professor in the department of clinical pharmacy at the University of Colorado, Aurora.
Is DKA prevention enough to justify universal screening?
Although identifying type 1 diabetes before symptoms arise could help avoid DKA, currently no therapeutic interventions are available to prevent or delay the trajectory from presymptomatic to clinical type 1 diabetes.
A possible future intervention – the anti-CD3 monoclonal antibody teplizumab (Tzield, Provention Bio) – had a setback in July 2021 when the Food and Drug Administration declined to approve it for the delay of type 1 diabetes in at-risk individuals.
However, on Feb. 22 Provention Bio announced that it has resubmitted the Biologics License Application for teplizumab for the delay of clinical type 1 diabetes in at-risk individuals. The FDA now has 30 days to review the resubmission, determine whether it is complete and acceptable for review, and provide a review goal date, according to a company statement.
But even without the ability to forestall the development of type 1 diabetes, screening proponents point to the potential benefit from educating families about early signs of diabetes onset and thereby preventing progression to DKA and both its short-term and possible long-term sequelae.
Prevention of DKA at diagnosis has been linked to improved long-term glycemic control and other potential health benefits.
And the frequency of DKA at the onset of type 1 diabetes has increased in recent years, to more than 20% in Germany and over 45% in the United States.
But, prior data have suggested that universal screening for presymptomatic type 1 diabetes is unlikely to be cost effective if only the health and economic benefits of prevention of DKA at type 1 diabetes onset is considered, unless the screening costs are exceedingly low.