Some pediatric patients with celiac disease whose condition is diagnosed after screening because a first-degree relative has the disease may appear asymptomatic but have severe disease histology, according to a new report.
About half of these patients had no symptoms, but disease histology was as severe as among those screened for other reasons, such as having symptomatic disease or high-risk conditions.
“This data supports current recommendations to screen all first-degree relatives of patients with celiac disease, especially pediatric patients in whom the ramifications of untreated disease may be significant,” wrote Michelle Gould, MD, and colleagues at the University of Toronto and McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont.
The study was published online in the Journal of Pediatric Gastroenterology and Nutrition.
Clinical characteristics
The incidence of celiac disease is higher among first-degree relatives of patients with the disease than among the general population, yet the clinical characteristics aren’t well described, the study authors wrote. Determining the clinical, serologic, and histologic phenotype of these patients could help clinicians determine whether continued universal screening of first-degree relatives is appropriate.
Dr. Gould and colleagues conducted a retrospective review of 227 patients diagnosed with celiac disease at McMaster Children’s Hospital between 1996 and 2014. The patients were categorized as being screened for celiac disease because a first-degree relative had the disease or because of other reasons. The other reasons included symptoms consistent with celiac disease or the presence of a high-risk clinical condition for which screening is recommended, such as type 1 diabetes or Down syndrome.
All patients were screened via tissue transglutaminase (tTG-IgA) tests. Positive serology was defined as tTG-IgA greater than the upper limit of normal in the presence of normal IgA immunoglobulin level for age.
The patients who were included in the study had biopsy-proven celiac disease in accordance with the Marsh criteria, which included Marsh III histology, Marsh II histology with positive serology, or Marsh I histology with positive serology and clinical symptoms.
The average age of the patients (144 girls and 83 boys) was 8 years at diagnosis. Among the patients, 49 (21.6%) were screened because a first-degree relative had celiac disease. Of those 49 patients, 24 (49%) were symptomatic, and 25 (51%) were asymptomatic.
By contrast, among the 178 patients who were screened for other reasons, 149 (83.7%) were symptomatic, and 29 (16.3%) were asymptomatic.
There was no significant difference between the patient groups with respect to Marsh score at biopsy and tTG-IgA levels at screening. Among the children who were screened because of family history, Marsh scores were equally severe as among other patients, whether they were symptomatic or not.
In addition, no statistically significant differences were found for other clinical characteristics, including body mass index z-score, weight z-score, height z-score, the presence of anemia, or a low mean corpuscular volume for age.
When comparing the characteristics of those screened because of family history and those screened for other high-risk conditions (type 1 diabetes and Down syndrome), the researchers found that rates of asymptomatic presentation were statistically similar between the groups, as were tissue transglutaminase values, Marsh scores, BMI z-scores, and hemoglobin levels at diagnosis. Although there was a statistical difference between the groups with respect to the mean corpuscular volume values at diagnosis, it was unlikely to be of clinical significance, the authors noted.
At 6 months, 1 year, and 2 years after diagnosis, among patients with repeat tTG-IgA measurements, 93 of 143 patients (65%), 52 of 68 patients (76.5%), and 80 of 90 patients (88.9%) had normal serum tTG-IgA levels, respectively. In comparing the proportion of patients whose tTG-IgA levels were normal, there was no difference between those screened because of family history and those screened for other reasons at any time point after diagnosis.
“This may suggest that the natural history of celiac disease is similar in these two groups following initiation of a gluten-free diet and that there are similar rates of compliance with this therapy regardless of the initial indication for screening,” the study authors wrote.