Acute respiratory disease associated with emerging adenovirus serotype 14 that caused nine deaths last fall in the United States is a development worth noting, but there seems little reason to fear this strain will lead to larger ongoing outbreaks of “killer colds.”
In fact, it is probably part of a natural life cycle that has been going on for millennia. We're only learning of these mutations in recent years because of active surveillance that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention now routinely conducts at sentinel sites around the country. When the system detects something noteworthy, the findings are published in the Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR). Media are mining the MMWR for stories, we're seeing frequent infectious disease stories with alarmist headlines. We should be prepared to explain them to worried parents of patients.
As we know, adenovirus typically isn't a life-threatening problem. In 99% of cases it's a self-limited infection that causes conjunctivitis, rhinorrhea, exudative pharyngitis, and/or fever for 3–8 days.
Adenovirus serotype 14 (Ad14) does appear to be a bit different, though: In May 2006, a 12-day-old infant in New York died of respiratory illness caused by “Ad14.” From March to June 2007, a total of 140 additional cases of confirmed Ad14 respiratory illness were identified in clusters of patients in Oregon, Washington, and Texas. Of those, 38% were hospitalized and 5% died (MMWR 2007;56:1181–4). Deaths were due to progressive pneumonias, not colds.
It's possible that Ad14 produces less frequent disease in young children than in the elderly, considering the relative ages of Ad14 patients. Among 12 cases with available medical information in Oregon, 11 (92%) of non-type-14 adenovirus patients were younger than 5 years, compared with only 5 (17%) out of 30 cases of Ad14. There was, however, one death in a 1-month-old in the Ad14 group.
But Ad14 is not new. It was initially described in 1955, and was associated with epidemic of acute respiratory disease in military recruits in Europe in 1969. According to the CDC, in 2001–2002 it was reported to be associated with approximately 8% of all respiratory adenoviral infections in the pediatric ward of a Taiwan Hospital.
However, because Ad14 hasn't been circulating in a while—it's just one of at least 42 different adenovirus strains—the current population isn't likely to be immune. While most healthy individuals are still able to mount an immune response to it, certain susceptible people will become more ill, including the very old, the very young, and those with compromised immune systems; perhaps some healthy people will have a genetic predisposition that makes them more vulnerable.
Indeed, a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP)—one change in the DNA of a key gene—can have a dramatic effect on how a person responds to environmental or infectious triggers. Consider as an example the case of a disease that we are more familiar with than Ad14, respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) in children. Hospitalization and more severe symptoms have been demonstrated with one SNP (Pediatr. Infect. Dis. J. 2007;26:1094–8), and it's likely that similar mechanisms explain some of the variation in disease severity with other viruses as well. We're just beginning to learn about these mechanisms within the innate immune system.
In the meantime, we might want to consider obtaining viral cultures—commercially available testing systems do include adenovirus—in hospitalized pneumonia patients who do not have positive RSV or influenza rapid tests and who do not improve quickly despite appropriate supportive and perhaps empiric antibiotic therapy.
Even though we don't have a commonly used effective antiviral for adenovirus, such as oseltamivir for influenza, it can be important to be aware of cases of severe adenovirus occurring outside of the surveillance network. While Ad14 is a recent culprit, other serotypes also have been implicated in sporadic outbreaks. Also, if you have a firm viral diagnosis, you don't need to keep escalating broad-spectrum antibiotics. Adenovirus can initially mimic the high fever, leukocytosis, and ill-appearing presentation of bacterial pneumonia, particularly in young children. The x-ray findings usually are bilateral and patchy initially, but the infiltrates can become dense and appear more “bacterial” as time goes on.
Another reason to culture for adenovirus is its potential to mimic Kawasaki disease, with the nonpurulent conjunctivitis, red throat, mucositis, high fever, and swollen lymph nodes. If you can confirm that the child actually has adenovirus during the Kawasaki work-up, you can save thousands of dollars that would otherwise be spent on intravenous immune globulin (IVIG) therapy. Of course, to be really useful, you'll need to get the viral cultures early, because current culture techniques—shell vial or standard—require anywhere from 48 hours to 7 days for results to develop. Because the window of effective use of IVIG in Kawasaki disease is within 10 days of the onset of fever, getting viral cultures more than 5 days into the fever may not give you time to make the diagnosis before you will need to empirically use IVIG.