News

Teens prescribed strict rest after concussions report more symptoms

View on the News

Tailor concussion recovery plans to individual

“Recent studies suggest that concussions account for more than 10% of all sport-related injuries sustained by high school athletes and reveal an increase in the number of children with concussions being cared for in emergency departments.… As noted by several medical societies, the evidence on which the recommendations for rest are based is sparse. This relative lack of evidence is due, in part, to the difficult nature of quantifying and tracking levels of physical and, particularly, cognitive activity. In this issue of Pediatrics, Thomas et al. take this challenge head on.

“The authors postulate that 5 days of strict rest requiring restrictions in activities may cause deleterious effects, namely an increase in emotional symptoms. This sentiment is consistent with our clinical impression, as well as emerging evidence suggesting that emotional symptoms increase over the course of recovery from concussion. Although this study adds some data on which to base recommendations for rest after a concussion, the optimal duration of rest after concussion remains unknown. Indeed, the optimal period of rest may vary, depending on age, gender, point in the calendar year, initial symptom level, the particular symptoms that predominate, the level of cognitive function, or other variables. As clinicians, we are forced to use the existing evidence, however limited, to develop a plan for our patients.
“In light of current consensus recommendations, previous investigations, and the study by Thomas et al., a recommendation of reasonable rest for the first few days after a concussion followed by a gradual resumption of cognitive activities seems prudent. The resumption of cognitive activities by patients who remain symptomatic may require instituting academic accommodations.… Given the variability of forces involved in different concussive injuries, the different symptom clusters and burdens experienced by patients who sustain concussions, and the observed variability of recovery patterns after concussion, the entire plan for managing a concussion should not be determined in the emergency department. Rather, a few days of rest followed by prompt follow-up with the pediatrician, sports medicine physician, or other capable provider should be recommended, and each management plan should be tailored to each individual patient.”

William P. Meehan III, M.D., of the Micheli Center for Sports Injury Prevention in Waltham, Mass., and the sports concussion clinic and the Brain Injury Center at Boston Children’s Hospital, and Richard G. Bachur, M.D., also of the Brain Injury Center, made these comments in an accompanying editorial (Pediatrics 2015 Jan. 5 [doi: 10.1542/peds.2014-3665]). Dr. Meehan receives royalties from ABC-Clio publishing for the sale of his book “Kids, Sports, and Concussion: A Guide for Coaches and Parents” and royalties from Wolters Kluwer for working as an author for UpToDate. His research is funded, in part, by a grant from the National Football Players Association and he has received philanthropic support from the National Hockey League Alumni Association. Dr. Bachur receives royalties from Wolters Kluwer for his work as editor for UpToDate and from Lippincott Williams & Wilkins for his work as editor of Textbook of Pediatric Emergency Medicine.


 

FROM PEDIATRICS

References

Teens advised to rest for 5 days after a concussion reported more post-concussive symptoms than teens who rested for 1-2 days and gradually returned to activity, based on results of a randomized, controlled study of 88 adolescents, aged 11 to 22.

“Although poor compliance with strict physical rest may have contributed to a lack of efficacy, previous adult studies that have assessed strict rest after concussion found similar results,” lead author Dr. Danny George Thomas and his associates at the Medical College of Wisconsin in Milwaukee reported online. The researchers also noted that “adolescents’ symptom reporting may be influenced by restricting activity” (Pediatrics 2015 Jan. 5 [doi: 10.1542/peds.2014-0966]).

Dr. Danny George Thomas

Dr. Danny George Thomas

Study participants reported to the Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin Emergency Department and Trauma Center between May 2010 and December 2012 within 24 hours of a concussion or mild traumatic brain injury. Most had injured their head during sports, primarily football, and about a third had lost consciousness. Those with an IQ below 70, a mental health or developmental condition or learning disability, or an intracranial injury were excluded.

After an initial neurocognitive, balance, and symptom assessment in the emergency department, 45 participants were randomly assigned to strict rest and 43 controls were randomly assigned to usual care. (Initial randomization involved 99 participants, but 11 did not complete all procedures.)

Usual care involved 24-48 hours of rest, followed by a return to school and a stepwise return to physical activity after symptoms resolved. The strict rest group were instructed to rest for 5 days at home with no school, work, or physical activity, and then gradually return to activity.

In addition to maintaining daily diaries of physical and mental activities, energy exertion and post-concussive symptoms, the participants underwent neurocognitive and balance assessments again at 3 and 10 days after their injury. The post-concussive symptoms recorded in the daily diaries came from the 19-symptom post concussion symptom scale, which rated physical, cognitive, emotional and sleep domains from 0 (none) to 6 (severe).

Energy exertion and physical activity levels were approximately 20% lower during the first 5 days post-concussion in both groups, but those assigned to strict rest had lower school and after-school activity attendance and mental activity during the 2-5 days after their injuries.

The strict rest group spent an average 3.8 hours in school or after-school activities, compared to 6.7 hours among the usual care group (P<.05). The strict rest participants also reported an average 4.9 hours of moderate and high mental activity during days 2-5 post-concussion, compared to an average 8.3 hours among the usual care participants.

Post-concussion neurocognitive and balance assessments did not identify any significant differences between the two groups. However, the strict rest group had a total average symptom score of 188 over 10 days, compared to a total score of 132 for the usual care group (P<.03). Total post-concussive symptoms during follow-up numbered 70 in the strict rest group and 50 in the usual care group.

Approximately 63% of the strict rest participants had their symptoms fully resolve during follow-up, compared to 67% of the usual care participants. Although this difference was not significant, it took took 3 days longer for half of the strict rest group to report fully resolved symptoms.

Results tended to vary slightly, however, depending on individuals’ concussion history and their symptoms at diagnosis. Those who had a history of concussion or were diagnosed based only on post-concussive symptoms had a higher post-concussive symptom score on the 10th day after injury if assigned to strict rest. But, those still experiencing immediate concussion symptoms at diagnosis had slightly lower post-concussive symptom scores at day 10 on strict rest, and those with a first concussion showed no differences between groups in post-concussive symptoms at day 10.

“There are many potential explanations for the difference in symptom reporting,” Dr. Thomas’s team wrote. “It is possible that discharge instructions influenced the perception of illness, augmenting symptom reporting” or that the slightly older strict rest group were better able to articulate their symptoms.

The authors also suggested that emotional distress caused by restrictions on school and activities may have caused emotional distress.

“Missing social interactions and falling behind academically may contribute to situational depression increasing physical and emotional symptoms,” they wrote. “Similarly, activity restrictions and lack of exercise may contribute to sleep abnormalities and adversely affect mood. Alternatively, attending less school may have resulted in more time and fewer distractions to thoughtfully complete symptom diaries or perseverate on symptoms.”The research was funded by the Injury Research Center of the Medical College of Wisconsin. The authors reported no disclosures.

Recommended Reading

Your son and football?
MDedge Pediatrics
Ketogenic diet halts refractory status epilepticus in kids
MDedge Pediatrics
VIDEO: Curative surgery possible for some kids with LGS epilepsy
MDedge Pediatrics
Seizure predictors may help guide EEG monitoring in kids
MDedge Pediatrics
VIDEO: Hype outstrips evidence on marijuana extracts for childhood epilepsy
MDedge Pediatrics
Periodic childhood syndromes may precede or shift to migraine
MDedge Pediatrics
Genetic studies trump metabolic tests to find cause of infantile spasms
MDedge Pediatrics
Modified Atkins diet is an alternative for intractable childhood epilepsy
MDedge Pediatrics
Adults with epilepsy diagnosis prefer full disclosure about sudden death risk
MDedge Pediatrics
Epileptologists more cautious when stopping kids’ AEDs a second time
MDedge Pediatrics