He said that he would advise them to find a mental health provider “that they trust with confidentiality, and to reach out to other people for support. I would also let them know about the physician assistance programs that are available. There’s one through Vanderbilt (the Vanderbilt Center for Professional Health) and several others that specialize in working with physicians who are struggling with mental health or substance abuse or disruptive behavior.”
Dr. Reynolds’ core message to distressed physicians is that “you’re a better doctor for your patients, and a better father or mother for your family, if you’re taking good care of yourself,” he said. “It’s hard for you to take care of your patients if you’re not also taking care of yourself, if you’re burning out. Get help. Treatment works.”
Dr. Christine Moutier, chief medical officer of the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, added that troubled physicians “should feel no shame for the fact that they’re in distress. Any of us can get there through a whole variety of different pathways that life presents. There’s science and data to support this experience as commonplace and having underpinnings that are of no fault to anyone. That’s the reality.”
Dr. Christine Moutier
Dr. Wible, who has lost several colleagues and physician friends to suicide, said that she hopes for a more transparent discussion of the topic by the medical profession. She presented on the topic at the 2014 annual scientific assembly of the American Academy of Family Physicians.
“The talk before mine was on Ebola, and every seat was taken” in the 900-seat room. When it came time for her presentation, “I maybe had 100 people in the room. Now, are physicians more likely to die from Ebola or from suicide? We are in a state of denial. If we don’t talk about suicide, we will continue to lose one or two medical students or doctors every day. The sooner we talk about this and connect with each other outside of a PowerPoint presentation, the sooner we’re going to solve this.”
After a physician in a large clinical department at the University of Pittsburgh took his own life several years ago, the chair of that department invited Dr. Reynolds to speak with his staff. The meeting “was primarily educational in nature, so we talked about the topic, to try to destigmatize and to educate people about the need for appropriate help-seeking,” recalled Dr. Reynolds, who is a former president of the American College of Psychiatrists. “If the leadership of a medical institution appropriately sanctions help-seeking behavior and treatment of mental disorders like depression, that’s going to make it okay for people to reach out and seek help rather than pushing it under the rug, so to speak. If the leadership says ‘this is a key thing and we don’t think you can function adequately as a medical student or as a physician if you’re not taking appropriate care of yourself,’ that helps to shift the culture.”
The ripple effect of that kind of message from health care administrators can’t be underestimated, said Dr. Moutier, who helped launch a suicide and depression awareness program at the University of California, San Diego (Acad. Med. 2012;87:320-6). She encouraged health care leaders to stage periodic grand rounds and lectures for their medical staff about physician well-being, burnout, and the risk of suicide. “If the leader is uncomfortable talking about these things, that’s a sign they should get a little education for themselves about [these topics],” she said.
Dr. Charles F. Reynolds III
Dr. Reynolds noted that certain state medical licensure boards including those for Arkansas and Pennsylvania have incorporated destigmatizing language into relicensure exams. “Some of them previously would ask questions such as whether the applicants had a history of a mental disorder like depression,” he said. “What you’re beginning to see now increasingly is that the state medical board will ask more generic questions, like ‘Do you have any conditions that would interfere with the practice of your specialty in medicine?’ This is a good thing.”
He said that he is optimistic about future of physician well-being, noting that the University of Pittsburgh and other medical schools have incorporated wellness principles into first-year curriculum. “We underscore the importance of students becoming sensitive to one another, learning how to recognize depression in each other and creating a culture in which students can encourage each other to engage in appropriate help-seeking,” Dr. Reynolds explained. “I think we are witnessing a shift in the culture of institutional medicine as we bring along new generations of physicians who are better educated about mental disorders and their treatment and issues related to suicide as we reach out to students, make counseling services available to them, educate them about these issues. That supports a cultural shift that gradually erodes the issue of stigma that has so long plagued appropriate help-seeking in medical institutions.”