Surgeons in the United States have been slow to adopt according to data from more than 6,000 patients.
Dr. Joceline V. Vu
“The benefit of MIS over open repair is recognized for patients with bilateral or recurrent inguinal hernias, and current guidelines recommend MIS repair for these cases,” wrote Joceline V. Vu, MD, of the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, and her colleagues.
In a study published in Surgical Endoscopy, the researchers assessed surgeons’ practice patterns for hernia repair, with a primary outcome of minimally invasive surgery (MIS) rates per individual surgeon. They reviewed data from a statewide clinical registry of 6,723 adults older than 18 years who underwent elective hernia surgery in Michigan between 2012 and 2016.
Overall, the surgeons’ use of MIS varied, but more than half (58%) of the surgeons performed no MIS for hernia repair. For those who did use MIS, it was used in 41% of bilateral hernias and 38% of recurrent hernias.
Surgeons were significantly less likely to use MIS for hernia on patients aged 65 years and older (odds ratio, 0.68, P = .003), or those who were black (OR 0.75, P = .045). MIS repair also was significantly less likely for patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (OR 0.57, P less than .001) or patients in American Society of Anesthesiologists Classification under 3 (OR 0.79, P less than .001).
Of the 227 surgeons who performed MIS, 71 (31%) had MIS utilization rates of 75% or higher and were defined as high-utilization surgeons. Overall, 75% of the MIS repairs were performed by 14% of the surgeons.
The surgeons with the highest use of MIS were unevenly distributed across the state; the Ann Arbor region had the highest percentage of high MIS-use surgeons (22%), compared with the Lansing area, in which 2% of surgeons were high users of MIS.
The risk-adjusted rate of MIS for inguinal hernia repair varied significantly across six regions of the state, from 10% to 48%, and the regions with the highest rates were those with the highest percentage of high-MIS use surgeons.
“These findings suggest that a large portion of decision making to offer MIS repair may depend on surgeon differences, rather than clinical appropriateness,” the researchers said. “The likelihood that a patient receives MIS repair may thus be predetermined by the surgeon to whom they are referred,” they added.
“Whether through novel training interventions or by establishing regional referral networks to improve access to MIS repair, improvement in MIS delivery and access is needed to reduce disparity and promote evidence-based practice,” they concluded.
The findings were limited by several factors including the potential for bias because of the observational nature of the study, the potential lack of generalizability of the findings, and lack of data on the particular attributes of the hernias, the researchers said.
Dr. Vu disclosed funding from the National Institutes of Health but had no financial conflicts to disclose. One of the study coauthors disclosed a relationship with Medtronic.
SOURCE: Vu JV et al. Surg Endosc. 2018 Jul 9. doi: 10.1007/s00464-018-6322-x.