The HeartMate 3 left ventricular assist device received a class 1 recall from the Food and Drug Administration on May 17, an action the agency publicly announced on May 22.
The FDA’s step formalized a “corrective action” that the HeartMate 3’s manufacturer, Abbott, first issued in early April and then announced in early May, which said the device used to treat patients with severe advanced heart failure was subject to “outflow graft twist occlusions” that trigger a persistent low-flow alarm and “can result in serious adverse events such as hemodynamic compromise, thrombus, and death,” according to the FDA’s May 17 statement.
Wikimedia Commons/FitzColinGerald/Creative Commons License
The class 1 recall category the FDA applied means the agency rates the danger posed as a “situation where there is a reasonable chance that a product will cause serious health problems or death.” However, in its statements, the agency has not suggested removing a well-functioning device from patients, nor has the agency called for discontinuing new placements of the HeartMate 3. The FDA gave a full endorsement to the approach Abbott suggested in its April 5 “Dear Physician” letter and then followed with a second letter on May 21.
The first letter attributed development of these twists in the tube that directs blood out from the device to accumulated mechanical forces from heartbeats, respiration, and activity, and also provided some management guidance that Abbott then expanded in its second letter.
The FDA cited some of the key steps Abbott recommended clinicians take with patients who receive a HeartMate 3. This included regular surveillance with transthoracic echocardiography, although echo is not considered definitive for identifying a graft twist obstruction and hence other investigations may also be needed. If the low-flow alarm sounds, a CT scan is “urgently” needed – as long as it’s not contraindicated – to identify a possible outflow twist. Abbott noted that surgical intervention may be needed to correct a twist.
Researchers recently reported 2-year follow-up data from 257 patients in MOMENTUM 3, the randomized pivotal trial for the HeartMate 3 that compared this fully magnetically levitated centrifugal-flow pump to the prior-generation, axial-flow pump. The composite endpoint of freedom from death, stroke, or need for repeat surgery after 2 years was 80% in the HeartMate 3 recipients and 60% among patients in the control arm who received the older-model device (N Engl J Med. 2018 April 12; 378[15]:1386-95).