From the Journals

Health issues in women midlife linked with health decline at 65


 

FROM JAMA NETWORK OPEN

Scoring system should not replace individualized evaluation, outside expert said

Commenting on the findings, Margaret J. Nachtigall, MD, a clinical associate professor in the department of obstetrics and gynecology at New York University Langone Health, cautioned that a generalized scoring system should not replace individualized evaluation of women at midlife.

Margaret J. Nachtigall, MD

Dr. Margaret J. Nachtigall

“I assess women around age 55 on a daily basis for health risk factors going forward. And while a number such as BMI can be helpful, I worry that reliance on a score could miss treating the individual,” Dr. Nachtigall said an interview. For instance, one woman might have a high BMI owing to greater muscle mass, which is heavy, while another may have a lower BMI but more fat-related weight, as well as exacerbating conditions such as hypertension that would elevate her risk. “You have to make the calculation for each person.”

Dr. Nachtigall, who was not involved in the SWAN analysis, noted, however, that a big-data scoring system might be a useful adjunct to individual patient evaluation in that “it would make physicians look at all these many risk factors to identify those prone to decline.”

Study includes racially diverse population

According to the authors, while other studies have identified similar and other risk factors such as poor sleep, most have not included such a racially diverse population and have focused on women already in their senior years when the window of opportunity may already have closed.

“As a clinician and epidemiologist, I often think about the window of opportunity at midlife, when people are vital, engaged, and resilient,” said Dr. Solomon in the statement. “If we can identify risk factors and determine who is at risk, we may be able to find interventions that can stave off health declines and help put people on a better health trajectory.”

Eric M Ascher, DO

Dr. Eric M. Ascher

Eric M. Ascher, DO, who practices family medicine at Lenox Hill Hospital in New York and was not involved in the SWAN research, agreed with Dr. Solomon.

“Doctors who treat chronic conditions often meet patients when they are already suffering from a medical problem,” he said in an interview. “It is key to decrease your risk factors before it is too late.”

Dr. Ascher added that many primary care providers already rely heavily on scoring systems when determining level of risk and type of intervention. “Any additional risk factor-scoring systems that are easy to implement and will prevent chronic diseases would be something providers would want to use with their patients.”

Detailed analyses of larger at-risk populations are needed to validate these risk factors and identify others, the authors said.

SWAN is supported by the National Institute on Aging, the National Institute of Nursing Research, and the National Institutes of Heath’s Office of Research on Women’s Health. Dr. Solomon reported financial ties to Amgen, AbbVie and Moderna, UpToDate, and Arthritis & Rheumatology; as well as serving on the board of directors for the Childhood Arthritis and Rheumatology Research Alliance and an advisory committee for the Food and Drug Administration outside of this work. Dr. Nachtigall and Dr. Ascher disclosed no conflicts of interest with regard to their comments.

Pages

Recommended Reading

Memory benefit seen with antihypertensives crossing blood-brain barrier
MDedge Cardiology
Stopping statins linked to death, CV events in elderly
MDedge Cardiology
Heart failure med undertreatment because of older age common, flouts evidence
MDedge Cardiology
Modest calorie reduction plus exercise linked with improved vascular health
MDedge Cardiology
How forgone heart failure care drives up costs
MDedge Cardiology
Omega-3s tame inflammation in elderly COVID-19 patients
MDedge Cardiology
Case: Older patient with T2D has recurrent flushing
MDedge Cardiology
No serious CV risks for elderly after Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine
MDedge Cardiology
Higher resting heart rate tied to increased dementia risk
MDedge Cardiology
Midlife cardiovascular conditions tied to greater cognitive decline in women
MDedge Cardiology