Choosing a Biologic
Refractory psoriasis involves nonresponse (primary failure) or return of disease symptoms after initial improvement (secondary failure) with a biologic. Selecting a biologic for patients who have experienced prior biologic failure is difficult. It is still unknown whether it is more efficacious for patients to try a same-class drug or a biologic targeting a different inflammatory pathway or cytokine. Studies have shown mixed results regarding how to manage patients with biologic failure, with both approaches demonstrating positive outcomes.
One analysis of the Corrona Psoriasis Registry included 144 patients, the majority of whom (89.8%) were biologic experienced, who began secukinumab treatment and returned for a 6-month follow-up (5–9 months).5 Patients enrolled in the registry were 18 years or older, had been diagnosed with psoriasis by a dermatologist, and initiated or switched an FDA-approved systemic agent or biologic within the last 12 months. Of biologic-experienced participants, 37.7% had used 3 or more biologics. More than half of included participants were either male (55%) or obese (53.4%). Comorbidities included hypertension (43.2%), hyperlipidemia (33.9%), anxiety (20.3%), diabetes mellitus (15.3%), cardiovascular disease (14.4%), and depression (13.6%). After 6 months of treatment, there was significant improvement in the involvement of BSA (mean difference, −12.1), investigator global assessment score (−1.5), dermatology life quality index (DLQI)(−4.8), pain (−23.2), itch (−30.8), fatigue (−8.8), and work productivity (−9.2)(P<.01). Secukinumab therapy displayed notable reduction in symptom severity in this population with difficult-to-treat psoriasis. Its relative success in this cohort provides support for its use in treating patients who have failed other classes of biologics.5
Evidence supporting reduction of pruritus and pain with secukinumab also was notable. The CLEAR phase 3 RCT involved participants treated with 300 mg secukinumab every week for the first 4 weeks and then every 4 weeks thereafter for 48 weeks (n=312), up to 100 weeks (n=277).6 Participants had complete relief of pain (score 0), itching, and scaling at week 16 (69.4%, 49.7%, and 61.2%, respectively), week 52 (67.1%, 48.9%, and 53.3%, respectively), and week 104 (70.9%, 47.4%, and 54.8%, respectively). Reported AEs included candida infections (7.2%), malignant or unspecified tumors (1.5%), and neutropenia (<1%).6
Researchers investigated intraclass switching to brodalumab with prior failure of IL-17 inhibitors. An open-label study involved participants (n=39) with prior failure with secukinumab or ixekizumab therapy.7 Participants were administered 210 mg brodalumab with standard dosing at weeks 0, 1, and 2, and then every 2 weeks thereafter. At week 16, 69% of participants achieved PASI-75, 44% achieved PASI-90, 28% achieved PASI-100, and 62% achieved an sPGA score of 0 or 1. The authors attributed the relative success of brodalumab compared to prior anti–IL-17 agents to inhibition of the IL-17 receptor with brodalumab rather than the IL-17A ligand.7 Brodalumab may be a useful alternative biologic for patients with nonresponse to and secondary failure with biologics, including the IL-17A inhibitors.
Recent findings support effective skin clearance and improved symptom management with ixekizumab and ustekinumab. Of note, ixekizumab was reported to provide rapid improvement in skin lesions and quality of life to a greater extent than guselkumab.
The IXORA-R double-blinded RCT compared the clinical benefit of participants 18 years and older taking standard approved dosages of ixekizumab (n=520) or guselkumab (n=507).8 Patients were included if they had plaque psoriasis for at least 6 months before baseline, an sPGA score of at least 3, PASI score of 12 or higher, 10% or greater BSA, no prior IL-17 inhibitor failure, no use of IL-23 p19 inhibitors, and no use of any biologic within the specified period prior to baseline. At week 12, ixekizumab showed superior clinical improvement measured by the proportion of participants achieving complete skin clearance (ie, PASI-100)(41%) compared to guselkumab (25%)(P<.001). There were more participants taking ixekizumab who reported DLQI of 0 or 1 (no impact of disease on quality of life)(34%) compared to guselkumab (21%)(P<.001) as early on as week 4. The most common AE was upper respiratory tract infection (7%) in both groups. The risk of treatment-emergent AEs (56%), discontinuation because of AEs (2%), and serious AEs (3%) were comparable in both groups. The number of injection-site reactions was higher with ixekizumab (13%) vs guselkumab (3%). The authors concluded that ixekizumab offers the ability to provide rapid relief of symptoms, which is associated with improved DLQI.8
Response to ustekinumab therapy was assessed in a patient cohort enrolled in the Corrona Psoriasis Registry. This study involved 178 participants 18 years and older with psoriasis involvement of 3% or greater BSA who were treated with ustekinumab.9 By their 6-month follow-up visit, 55.6% of participants achieved adequate treatment response (BSA improving to <3% or 75% from enrollment). Increasing patient age was significantly associated with decreased likelihood of achieving a response (odds ratio, 0.981 [95% confidence interval, 0.962-0.999]; P=.049). Ustekinumab is a practical option for psoriasis treatment that seems to yield better results in younger patients.9 This evidence reveals that increased patient age is a characteristic that may contribute to poor treatment response and should be considered when choosing the best fit for biologic therapy.
Final Thoughts
Using evidence-based interventions to treat patients is the cornerstone of ethical and high-quality medical care. This guide sought to provide relevant updates in a variety of both comparator and pivotal trials, with the goal of summarizing clinically relevant information that may be extracted from these trials to guide patient care. It is not an exhaustive review but may be utilized as a reference tool to fine-tune selection criteria in choosing 1 of 11 biologics for the treatment of psoriasis.