Just 3 years ago, Michigan had the fourth-highest rate of unvaccinated kindergartners in the nation. But, when a charter school in northwestern Traverse City reported nearly two dozen cases of whooping cough and several cases of measles that November, state officials were jolted to action.
Without much fanfare – or time for opponents to respond – they abandoned the state’s relatively loose rules for getting an exemption and issued a regulation requiring families to consult personally with local public health departments before obtaining an immunization waiver.
The new rule sidestepped potential ideological firefights in the state legislature, which have plagued lawmakers in other states who are trying to crack down on vaccination waivers. The regulation had a dramatic effect. In the first year, the Michigan Department of Health & Human Services reported that the number of statewide waivers issued had plunged 35%. Today, Michigan is in the middle of the pack among vaccination rates.
“The idea was to make the process more burdensome,” said Michigan State University health policy specialist Mark Largent, PhD, who has written extensively about vaccines. “Research has shown that, if you make it more inconvenient to apply for a waiver, fewer people get them.”
Michigan’s experience demonstrates a way for governments to increase immunization rates without having to address religious or philosophical opposition to vaccines.
For many years, opposition to mandatory childhood vaccines has served as a frequent rallying point for those who see immunizations as interference with nature’s intentions, rebel against them as government meddling in family affairs, or raise concerns about their safety.
Vaccine advocates and health professionals regard these views as dangerous, noting that the drugs have dramatically lowered the number of serious childhood illnesses and that studies suggesting they are not safe have been debunked. They also note that vaccines’ proven effectiveness lies in “herd immunity” – the higher the participation rate, the greater the community’s protection against outbreaks of infectious disease.
Many states adopt strategies to curb exemptions “by making applications complicated to fill out or complete,” according to University of Georgia public policy expert W. David Bradford, PhD, who studies immunization. Some states require parents to notarize applications or have them certified by a physician before sending them in, and, “generally speaking, anything that raises the opportunity cost [of exemptions] works to some degree,” Bradford said. “Michigan took it a step further.”
Increasing the number of vaccinated kids in Michigan, which has a Republican governor and Republican majorities in both legislative houses, took a degree of political finesse.
“Health & Human Services wanted to do something, but the legislative option wasn’t there,” Dr. Largent said. Instead, Michigan decided to use a strategy he calls “inconvenience.”
Since 1978, Michigan had required schoolchildren entering kindergarten and middle school to obtain vaccination waiver certificates from county officials. “Some counties allowed you to do it over the phone; in others you mailed in a form and some even let you do it online,” Dr. Largent said. But, in studying vaccine policy across the country, he noted, “One thing is really clear – health departments that require you to go in and get the waiver have much lower rates.”
Michigan offered the perfect vehicle for introducing inconvenience into the process. The Joint Committee on Administrative Rules reviews state agency regulations and, if it takes no action, allows them to go into effect after 15 legislative days. The committee is composed of lawmakers, giving it a legislative imprimatur, but it is not the legislature itself, thus avoiding the political rancor that can accompany debate on controversial issues.
During the 2013-14 school year, the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention found that Michigan had the fourth-highest rate of children entering kindergarten who had been exempted from vaccinations. The state Health & Human Services officials proposed a simple requirement: Parents seeking vaccine waivers must be briefed in person by a county health educator before a waiver would be granted. The joint committee approved the rule Dec. 11, 2014. It took effect Jan. 1, 2015.
“We were not aware of the rule until the day it happened,” said Suzanne Waltman, president of Michigan for Vaccine Choice, an antivaccine organization. “We thought it was a stealth move.”
The office of Gov. Rick Snyder did not respond directly to requests for comment on the political hazards of vaccine policy. Retired Republican state Sen. John Pappageorge, cochair of the administrative rules committee in 2014, voted to adopt the rule and described the procedure as a simple one designed to ensure “that implementation is in concurrence with the law.” Republican Rep. Tom McMillin, who was cochair of the committee at the time and voted against the rule, did not respond to requests for an interview.
In a look at one key metric, before 2015, about 22% of Michigan children did not get the fourth round of immunizations for diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussis that is required by the state. That had fallen to 15% 1 year later, slightly better than the national average.
The Traverse City outbreaks were overshadowed in the national media by a more dramatic measles outbreak in Southern California’s Disneyland, which also occurred over the 2014-15 holidays and ultimately led to 150 cases of the disease. But the states’ responses were quite different.
California’s solution was what Dr. Largent calls “eliminationism.” The state Legislature, with Democratic supermajorities, passed a measure doing away with religious and philosophical vaccine exemptions. Passage of the law triggered widespread protests among opponents of vaccines. Besides California, only West Virginia and Mississippi disallow nonmedical waivers.
Dr. Largent said a small number of children need waivers for medical reasons, usually because of allergies or immune deficiencies. Much larger numbers seek waivers for religious or philosophical reasons.
“The idea was to bring the waiver rate down,” Michigan Health & Human Services spokeswoman Angela Minicuci said. “From the perspective of the general population, vaccinations are recommended. This doesn’t take away choice. It simply ensures that people have education.”
But, Dr. Largent said most vaccine opponents are not necessarily swayed by arguments in favor of immunization. Instead, “by heightening the burden, you change some of the incentives” for obtaining waivers. “Moral claims and ideology don’t matter as much when it’s inconvenient.”
Kaiser Health News is a national health policy news service that is part of the nonpartisan Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation.