Beyond clinical assessment, laboratory diagnostic testing generally plays a limited role in guiding appropriate antibiotic prescribing for patients with an ARTI.2,3 Most diagnostic tests require 2 or 3 days to result, incur additional costs, and may delay treatment.4 While these tests do not provide clear and timely guidance on which specific antibiotic is appropriate for ARTI patients, this is not the case for patients with pharyngitis.5,6,7 A rapid diagnostic test exists to identify pharyngitis patients with GABHS which accounts for 1 in 4 children with acute sore throat.1,4,6 Both the American Academy of Pediatrics and the Infectious Diseases Society of America recommend antibiotic treatment for children and adolescents under 18 years of age who have a positive test for group A Streptococcus (GAS).8,9 This “test and treat” protocol has been consistently included in the Healthcare Effectiveness Data and Information Set (HEDIS) standards over time for pediatric pharyngitis patients aged 3 to 18 years before dispensing an antibiotic.10
Sinusitis, pneumonia, and acute otitis media are considered ARTIs where antibiotic treatment is justified. Therefore, pharyngitis of unclear etiology seen with these comorbid infections may not always undergo GAS testing but move directly to the patient being prescribed antibiotics. This analysis enumerates ARTI-related comorbidities present together with the initial coded pharyngitis diagnosis to evaluate their impact on the provider’s decision to test and treat, and on revisit risk.
Antibiotic treatment for GAS patients is likely to eradicate the acute GABHS infection within 10 days. Penicillin and amoxicillin are commonly recommended because of their narrow spectrum of activity, few adverse effects, established efficacy, and modest cost. Alternative antibiotics for patients with penicillin allergy, or with polymicrobial infection seen on culture results, include a first-generation cephalosporin, clindamycin, clarithromycin (Biaxin), or azithromycin (Zithromax).1,8,11 However, while compliance with these HEDIS guidelines has been evaluated, the outcome effects of following the HEDIS “test and treat” recommendations for children with pharyngitis have not been adequately evaluated.
These outcome evaluations have increasing importance as the latest HEDIS survey has shown testing rates in commercial Preferred Provider Organizations (PPO) falling from 86.4% in 2018 to 75.9% in 2019, the lowest rate of testing since 2009, with similar reductions under 80% for Health Maintenance Organizations (HMO).10 While health plans may execute cost-benefit analyses and algorithms to forge best practices for GAS testing in children and adolescents presenting with symptoms of pharyngitis, it is important to regard the wasteful resource utilization and additional cost of revisits that may offset any gains accrued by more focused GAS testing outside the existing clinical guidelines and HEDIS measures. This may be of particular importance in documenting infection and sparing antibiotic therapy in toddlers and younger.
The objective of this study was to investigate the correlation between testing and antibiotic use on the likelihood of a revisit for an acute respiratory tract infection within 28 days. To achieve this objective, this investigation consists of 3 sequential analyses. First, we document the factors associated with the decision to test the patient for a GABHS infection using the GAS test. Next, we document the factors associated with the decision to use an antibiotic to treat the patient as a function of having tested the patient. Finally, we investigate the impact of the testing and treatment decisions on the likelihood of a revisit within 28 days.