News

CBT improves depression but not self-care in heart failure patients

View on the News

Talk more, prescribe less

When depression occurs in patients with heart failure, which is often, the illness burden and management complexity increase multifold. Freedland et al. tested the hypothesis that the effective treatment of comorbid depression with cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) would also lead to improvements in heart failure self-care and physical functioning and found that it did not. The good news is that CBT did significantly improve emotional health and overall quality of life, and the improvement in depressive symptoms associated with CBT was larger than observed in pharmacotherapy trials for depression in patients with heart disease. This supports evidence for a shift in practice away from so much pharmacotherapy and more use of psychotherapy to achieve better mental health and overall quality of life outcomes in patients with heart failure. In reframing how we think about the management of depression in patients with heart failure, we should be talking more and prescribing less.

Dr. Patrick G. O’Malley is deputy editor of JAMA Internal Medicine. He declared no competing interests. These comments were taken from his accompanying editorial (JAMA Intern Med. 2015 Sept. 28).


 

FROM JAMA INTERNAL MEDICINE

References

Cognitive behavioral therapy significantly improved major depression but did not improve self-care by heart failure patients, investigators reported online in JAMA Internal Medicine.

“The results suggest that CBT is superior to usual care for depression in patients with heart failure,” said Dr. Kenneth Freedland and his associates at Washington University in St. Louis. They called the findings “especially encouraging” in light of recent negative results from the SADHART-CHF and MOOD-HF trials of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors in this population.Patients in heart failure often have major depression, which increases their chances of poor self-care, hospitalization, and mortality, the researchers noted. Their single-blind, randomized trial included 158 patients who were in New York Heart Association class I, II, or III heart failure and met criteria for major depression. Patients in the intervention group received standard medical care, plus up to 6 months of CBT designed for cardiac patients.Patients received CBT weekly, then biweekly, and then monthly as they reached their treatment goals, but they also received telephone follow-up to help prevent relapse. The control group received standard medical care plus consultation with a cardiac nurse, written materials on heart failure self-care, and three follow-up phone calls with the nurse (JAMA Intern Med. 2015 Sept. 28. doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2015.5220). At 6 months, the CBT group scored significantly lower on the BDI-II than did controls (mean score, 12.8 [standard deviation, 10.6] vs. 17.3 [10.7]; P = .008), the researchers said. Remission rates with CBT were 46% based on the BDI-II and 51% based on the Hamilton Depression Scale, both of which significantly exceeded remission rates of 19-20% for controls. The CBT group also improved significantly more than did controls on standard measures for anxiety, heart failure-related quality of life, mental health–related quality of life, fatigue, and social functioning, but not on measures of physical functioning, the researchers reported.

The National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute partially funded the study. The researchers declared no competing interests.

Recommended Reading

Relationship between depression and adolescent obesity unclear, study finds
MDedge Psychiatry
Community cancer programs best for psychosocial care
MDedge Psychiatry
Study: Bipolar mothers’ interaction with infants weaker than unipolar mothers’
MDedge Psychiatry
Data grow in support of ECT for depression
MDedge Psychiatry
Data showing CBT extends ECT’s effectiveness raise more questions
MDedge Psychiatry
Screen for depression in adolescents, USPSTF recommends
MDedge Psychiatry
Psoriasis patients more likely to have type D personalities
MDedge Psychiatry
Paroxetine found neither safe nor effective for adolescent depression
MDedge Psychiatry
Tactics for suicide intervention at hot spots are effective
MDedge Psychiatry
Exercise found protective against effects of bullying, suicide
MDedge Psychiatry