Commentary

Homelessness: A need for better care


 

Should homelessness alone be a criterion for mental health treatment?

Despite the enormous challenges facing the homeless population, many are seen in our clinics hopeful and endorsing a fair mood. Many are polite and answer questions in an attempt to diminish the burden they feel they impose on others, including the medical system. Many display strong resiliency and find ways to cope, relate, and find meaning despite their challenging circumstances. Yet, many also come to us suffering and seeking assistance.

Dr. Mari Janowsky is a combined resident in family medicine and psychiatry at the University of California, San Diego. She spends most of her clinical time at St. Vincent de Paul Family Health Center, a clinic that primarily serves the homeless.

Dr. Mari Janowsky

We empathize with the frustration psychiatrists feel when using terms such as “homelessidal” to refer to patients who are homeless and suicidal. The term is meant to evoke the perceived helplessness in trying to care for a homeless patient in the emergency department. Although 2 days of housing in an inpatient psychiatric unit and prescribing an antidepressant can give homeless patients a brief respite, it does little to address the root cause of that person’s suffering. We also find that the use of diagnostic labels can be insufficient, and often inappropriate, in the context of the expected reactions to the significant stressors of being homeless.

We routinely see the distress and hopelessness in our patients suffering from homelessness. We think that psychiatry is capable of softening those daily traumas using supportive therapy. We think that psychiatry is capable of positively challenging the despondency by activating meaning and purpose, as suggested by Dr. Frankl. While those are not typical interventions in modern psychiatry, they are established and validated. By considering homelessness in and of itself a criterion for mental health treatment, we can begin to address those challenges, and engage in alternative, longer lasting treatment considerations.

How to proceed?

Though the answer for caring for the homeless may not be in psychopharmacology, we think that psychiatry could enhance the care of the homeless by pursuit of two main goals.

Recommended Reading

Hidradenitis suppurativa packs mighty QOL impact
MDedge Psychiatry
Anticholinergics’ link to dementia calls for vigilance in elderly
MDedge Psychiatry
VIDEO: National suicide hotline could result from pending U.S. law
MDedge Psychiatry
Targeting inactivity, mood, and cognition could be key to reducing OA mortality
MDedge Psychiatry
Suicidality assessment of people with autism needs better tools
MDedge Psychiatry
VIDEO: Novel postpartum depression drug effective in phase 3 trial
MDedge Psychiatry
Commentary: Shifting the care delivery paradigm to diabetes-depression collaborative care models
MDedge Psychiatry
U.S. youth suicide prevention saved nearly 900 lives
MDedge Psychiatry
MDedge Daily News: How to handle opioid constipation
MDedge Psychiatry
Suicide prevention starts with the patient’s narrative
MDedge Psychiatry