From the Journals

Any mental disorder increases risk for all mental disorders

View on the News

Diagnoses must be made ‘in a new way’

The study’s large, population-based sample supports the findings of pervasive and bidirectional comorbidity across all areas of psychopathology, Steven E. Hyman, MD, wrote in an accompanying editorial.

“As the authors recognize, this bidirectionality provides new evidence for the sharing of risk architecture across mental disorders,” Dr. Hyman said.

Dr. Hyman added that the data from the study, available via website for access by clinicians and patients, represent an important public health contribution by providing insight into factors that might increase risk for comorbid mental health conditions. However, the data must be interpreted and used with caution, he said, and users must be “educated not to interpret this type of probabilistic information in an excessively pessimistic and fatalistic manner – an issue that is not unique to this risk predictor,” he said.

Dr. Hyman added that, although the findings support theories on the shared factor models for pathogenesis of mental disorders, new classification proposals and research into the genetics of mental disorders are in the early stages. “Indeed, if research is to advance the laudable desire of the authors to contribute to prevention of new incident diagnoses, Plana-Rapoll et al. have helped their cause by pointing out that we must make diagnoses in a new way,” he said (JAMA Psychiatry. 2019 Jan 16. doi: 10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2018.4269).

Dr. Hyman is affiliated with the Stanley Center for Psychiatric Research at Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard in Cambridge, Mass. He disclosed personal fees for serving on the scientific advisory boards of Janssen, BlackThorn Therapeutics, and F-Prime Capital Partners, and personal fees for serving on the board of directors of Voyager Therapeutics and Q-State Biosciences.


 

FROM JAMA PSYCHIATRY

Diagnosis of any mental disorder significantly increased the risk for all other mental disorders, based on data from a population-based cohort study of almost 6 million individuals followed for nearly 84 million person-years.

Comorbidity among mental disorders has been acknowledged, but comprehensive data on comorbidities across all subsets of disease and a comprehensive risk assessment has been lacking, wrote Oleguer Plana-Ripoll, PhD, of Aarhus University in Denmark, and his colleagues.

In a study published in JAMA Psychiatry, the researchers included all individuals born in Denmark between Jan. 1, 1900, and Dec. 31, 2015, who were living in Denmark between Jan. 1, 2000, and Dec. 31, 2016. They used national health registries to identify mental disorders, and diagnoses were based on the International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems. The study population included 2,958,293 men and 2,982,485 women with an average age of 32 years at the start of the follow-up period; participants were followed for a total of 83.9 million person-years. Mental disorders were categorized in groups, and groups were paired for risk assessment.

Overall, the risk of developing all other mental disorders increased with the diagnosis of one mental disorder, most prominently in the first year after diagnosis, but the risk persisted for at least 15 years. In one model controlling for age, calendar time, and sex, hazard ratios ranged from 2.0 for prior intellectual disabilities paired with later eating disorders to 48.6 for prior developmental disorders paired with later intellectual disabilities.

The large sample size allowed for focus on absolute risk and the study was accompanied by an interactive website (http://www.nbepi.com) that allows clinicians (and potentially patients) to monitor possible emerging mental health comorbidities.

As one example of absolute risk assessment, the researchers determined that 40% of men and 50% of women diagnosed with a mood disorder before age 20 years would develop an incident neurotic disorder as defined by the 10th revision of the International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems within the next 15 years. “The provision of absolute risk estimates may facilitate the clinical translation of our findings, and lay the groundwork for future studies related to personalized medicine and the primary prevention of comorbidity,” Dr. Plana-Ripoll and his colleagues wrote.

The researchers acknowledged the study’s limitation of comorbidities to pairs of disorders versus three or more, the use of groups of disorders rather than specific disorders, and the limitation to mental disorders treated in secondary care settings. However, the data support findings from previous studies and “provide new insights into the complex nature of comorbidity and the comprehensive nature of the analysis will provide an important foundation for future research,” they said.

The research was supported by the Danish National Research Foundation. Dr. Plana-Ripoll had no financial conflicts to disclose. Some coauthors disclosed grants from the National Institutes of Health, Novo Nordisk Foundation, and the European Research Council, and some coauthors disclosed financial relationships with Sanofi Aventis, Johnson & Johnson, Sage Pharmaceuticals, Shire, and Takeda.

SOURCE: Plana-Ripoll O et al. JAMA Psychiatry. 2019 Jan 16. doi: 10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2018.3658.

Recommended Reading

Antidepressants tied to greater hip fracture incidence in older adults
MDedge Psychiatry
White matter volume reduced in first-episode depression
MDedge Psychiatry
Gender, racial, socioeconomic differences found in obesity-depression link
MDedge Psychiatry
Naltrexone/ketamine combo may reduce depressive symptoms in MDD/AUD patients
MDedge Psychiatry
Mental health patients flocking to emergency departments
MDedge Psychiatry
A prescription for ‘deprescribing’: A case report
MDedge Psychiatry
Opioid crisis offers poignant lessons for public health
MDedge Psychiatry
Rural suicidality and resilience
MDedge Psychiatry
Family estrangement: Would mutual respect make a difference?
MDedge Psychiatry
Medicaid youth suicides include more females, younger kids, hanging deaths
MDedge Psychiatry