An old idea–using peers to facilitate recovery–is gaining new attention from public mental health specialists as they search for ways to help the mentally ill get care in an overstretched system and return to productivity.
Peer counseling is the foundation of Alcoholics Anonymous, Narcotics Anonymous, and similar groups that tap people during their recovery to help others get on the same path.
The counselors “can provide a powerful message of hope for people who are hopeless,” said Sue Bergeson, executive vice president of the Depression and Bipolar Support Alliance. They also “stand with that individual through their journey through recovery,” said Ms. Bergeson in an interview.
The DBSA believes that peer support improves recovery and is participating in a research project with Dr. Greg E. Simon, a psychiatrist at Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound's Center for Health Studies, Seattle, to document the impact of peer support on patient outcomes compared with traditional care.
In the mental health field, people in recovery from depression, bipolar disorder, and other psychiatric conditions may offer one-on-one advice, lead mutual support groups, or staff desks at drop-in centers where they can counsel peers on finding employment and managing day-to-day living issues.
Several self-help groups have been around for decades: GROW Inc., Recovery Inc., and Schizophrenics Anonymous, for instance.
Peer support–which is defined partly as the sharing of experiential knowledge, skills, and social learning–was included as 1 of the 10 fundamental components of recovery in a consensus statement that was recently released by the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration.
Backers of peer support say it improves outcomes and reduces costs. In an overview of the field, Phyllis L. Solomon, Ph.D., professor of social work at the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, cited numerous studies showing that peer support programs improve symptoms, coping, social functioning, and medication adherence, as well as reduce hospitalizations and use of crisis services (Psychiatr. Rehabil. J. 2004;27:392–401).
Preliminary, yet-to-be-published data from a Georgia study show that peer support improved symptoms and patient functioning at half the cost of traditional care in Medicaid recipients with schizophrenia, depression, and bipolar disorder, said Larry Fricks, former director for consumer relations in the Georgia Department of Human Resources.
However, peer support is not meant to replace therapy–whether talk therapy or medication–provided by a licensed psychiatrist or psychologist.
In Georgia, for instance, where peer services are billable under Medicaid as a psychiatric rehabilitation benefit, a patient who enters the public mental health system is diagnosed by a clinician, who then can recommend peer support as one of the steps toward recovery, said Mr. Fricks, who is now director of the Appalachian Consulting Group in Cleveland, Ga.
The state will bill Medicaid $7 million this year for peer support, Mr. Fricks said in an interview. About 3,000 people are receiving peer support services in Georgia, he said.
He is in recovery from bipolar disorder, and his consulting company is working with the federal government to adopt the Georgia model for use in other states.
Those seeking to become counselors in Georgia have to document that they are in recovery and must go through a certification process. About 300 people have completed that process, which includes two weeklong training modules and a written and oral exam.
Peer specialists are expected to help patients create a recovery action plan, find a job, handle employment-related issues, and learn how to use community and other support systems.
South Carolina and Hawaii have already begun peer certification programs, and seven other states are in the early stages, Mr. Fricks said.
Training is crucial, said Dr. Jana Spalding, the mental health specialist in the Broward County Sheriff's Office in Fort Lauderdale, Fla. Florida is one of the states seeking to start certification and receive Medicaid reimbursement.
“Just because you got better doesn't mean you can help other people,” said Dr. Spalding in an interview. Peer counselors have to demonstrate competency, be able to establish a rapport with someone who might be psychotic, and must be nonjudgmental and knowledgeable about medications, their side effects, and community resources, she said.
Dr. Spalding's professional path to pediatrics was interrupted several times and eventually derailed by her bipolar disease. She ended up taking a job at the peer support center where she had been receiving assistance.
Now, through the sheriff's office, she and a team of psychologists work with mentally ill inmates. Dr. Spalding considers it a successful day if she can get an inmate who is in solitary confinement to interact with other inmates or the psychologists by playing games or watching movies, for instance.