Commentary

Identifying and preventing IPV: Are clinicians doing enough?


 

Violence against women remains a global dilemma in need of attention. Physical violence in particular, is the most prevalent type of violence across all genders, races, and nationalities.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says more than 43 million women and 38 million men report experiencing psychological aggression by an intimate partner in their lifetime. Meanwhile, 11 million women and 5 million men report enduring sexual or physical violence and intimate partner violence (IPV), and/or stalking by an intimate partner during their lifetimes, according to the CDC.1

Dr. Suneeta Kumari


Women who have endured this kind of violence might present differently from men. Some studies, for example, show a more significant association between mutual violence, depression, and substance use among women than men.2 Studies on the phenomenon of IPV victims/survivors becoming perpetrators of abuse are limited, but that this happens in some cases.

Having a psychiatric disorder is associated with a higher likelihood of being physically violent with a partner.3,4 One recent study of 250 female psychiatric patients who were married and had no history of drug abuse found that almost 68% reported psychological abuse, 52% reported sexual abuse, 38% social abuse, 37% reported economic abuse, and 25% reported physical abuse.5

Given those statistics and trends, it is incumbent upon clinicians – including those in primary care, psychiatry, and emergency medicine – to learn to quickly identify IPV survivors, and to use available prognostic tools to monitor perpetrators and survivors.

COVID pandemic’s influence

Isolation tied to the COVID-19 pandemic has been linked to increased IPV. A study conducted by researchers at the University of California, Davis, suggested that extra stress experienced during the COVID-19 pandemic caused by income loss, and the inability to pay for housing and food exacerbated the prevalence of IPV early during the pandemic.6

Dr. Elohor Otite

Dr. Elohor Otite

That study, where researchers collected in surveys of nearly 400 adults in the beginning in April 2020 for 10 weeks, showed that more services and communication are needed so that frontline health care and food bank workers, for example, in addition to social workers, doctors, and therapists, can spot the signs and ask clients questions about potential IPV. They could then link survivors to pertinent assistance and resources.

Furthermore, multiple factors probably have played a pivotal role in increasing the prevalence of IPV during the COVID-19 pandemic. For instance, disruption to usual health and social services as well as diminished access to support systems, such as shelters, and charity helplines negatively affected the reporting of domestic violence.

Long before the pandemic, over the past decade, international and national bodies have played a crucial role in terms of improving the awareness and response to domestic violence.7,8 In addition, several policies have been introduced in countries around the globe emphasizing the need to inquire routinely about domestic violence. Nevertheless, mental health services often fail to adequately address domestic violence in clinical encounters. A systematic review of domestic violence assessment screening performed in a variety of health care settings found that evidence was insufficient to conclude that routine inquiry improved morbidity and mortality among victims of IPV.9 So the question becomes: How can we get our patients to tell us about these experiences so we can intervene?

Pages

Recommended Reading

Antidepressants: Is less more?
MDedge Psychiatry
Emotions, science, and the politics of COVID
MDedge Psychiatry
Family-oriented care in adult psychiatric residency
MDedge Psychiatry
Mental health problems in kids linked with school closures
MDedge Psychiatry
Psychiatry resident’s viral posts reveal his own mental health battle
MDedge Psychiatry
GAP looks back on 75 years of shaping psychiatry
MDedge Psychiatry
Physician burnout, depression compounded by COVID: Survey
MDedge Psychiatry
Things reproductive psychiatrists might ‘always’ or ‘never’ do in 2022
MDedge Psychiatry
Hormone therapy in transgender teens linked to better adult mental health
MDedge Psychiatry
Ways to make sure 2022 doesn’t stink for docs
MDedge Psychiatry