Commentary

The accelerating societal entropy undermines mental health

Author and Disclosure Information

 

References

According to the second law of thermo­dynamics, it is inevitable that entropy will continue to increase over time.1 Entropy is a measure of disorder, which can eventuate in chaos and lead to profound uncertainty, with serious psychological consequences.

The increase in entropy is usually gradual. It took hundreds of years for powerful empires and civilizations to collapse and disappear. Inanimate objects such as a house, a piece of furniture, or a piece of equipment eventually deteriorate and break down over time. Tidy offices will become messy, cluttered, and dirty unless attended to regularly. Living organisms, including humans, inevitably undergo an aging process with cell­ular senescence, atrophy, and loss of cerebral, muscle, and bone tissue, ending in death. Even human relationships will eventually fracture, wither, and end. The passage of time ruthlessly increases the entropy of everything in life. Even the 13-billion-year-old universe, which currently looks formidable and permanent to us, is inexorably expanding and hurtling towards a calamitous end a few billion years from now.

To slow down, halt, or reverse entropy, work and energy must be invested. A house requires regular maintenance for all its components to avoid deteriorating and becoming uninhabitable (very high entropy). Humans require massive amounts of work during fetal life, infancy, childhood, adolescence, adulthood, and throughout old age. This includes work by parents, teachers, friends, physicians, farmers, and manufacturers of food, clothing, and sundry supplies, all targeted to maintain an individual and slow the rate of entropy. But death is inevitable as the final stage of human entropy.

The brain is an entropic organ.2 Psychiatric disorders can be conceptualized as a neurobiologic consequence of a major rise in brain entropy. The chaos created by high brain entropy will lead to a disruption of basic mental functions such as thought, mood, affect, impulses, behavior, and cognition. Brain entropy increases can be due to genetics or the environment, but most often are due an interaction of both (G x E).

Societal entropy and our patients

Psychiatric patients are deeply influenced by the context in which they live (society). The entropy of contemporary society is rising at an alarming rate, which means that order is rapidly degenerating into disorder at an unprecedented pace. When the COVID-19 pandemic abruptly emerged in early 2020, it was a major public health shock that drastically changed the lives of all citizens and dramatically increased societal entropy. The pandemic led to lockdowns, fear of death, gut-wrenching uncertainty (especially for a whole year before vaccines were developed, but even after), loss of socialization and sexual intimacy, loss of employment, financial straits, and an inability to access routine medical or surgical procedures. Everyone in society developed anxiety and acute stress reaction, but those with pre-existing psychiatric disorders suffered the most with an intensification of their symptoms.

The unforeseen, sudden, and traumatically life-altering pandemic triggered various degrees of posttraumatic stress disorder across all age groups, and painful death in medically compromised individuals and older adults. Both physical and psychological entropy skyrocketed and the “order” of life as we knew it rapidly disintegrated into shambles and disorder. The abrupt traumatic jolt triggered various degrees of deleterious impacts on the brains of all who experienced it in real time. The rise in the psychobiological entropy was unprecedented across the structures of society, especially the population, its vulnerable human component.

But even as the worst of the pandemic is in our rearview mirror and life again has a semblance of normality, the rise of entropy continues to accelerate because we continue to be surrounded and engulfed by countless stressful events in contemporary society. Those nagging stresses continue to transmute order to chaos and metamorphose comforting predictability to entrenched uncertainty:

  • Toxic political hyperpartisanship, with intense animus and visceral bi­directional hatred
  • Racial tensions, with overt bias across groups
  • Economic turmoil, with inflation and threats of recession
  • Actual wars and threats of war
  • Social media that spreads bad news and distorts facts
  • An opioid crisis, with hundreds of thousands of deaths
  • Skyrocketing crime, with a decline in policing and quick release of criminals without bail
  • A ruthless and arbitrary “cancel culture” that doesn’t even spare the previously revered founders of the republic
  • Cognitive dissonance of disparaging Abraham Lincoln despite his major achievement of eliminating slavery by waging a civil war
  • The social and medical strife regarding access to abortion.

Continue to: I also would include...

Pages

Recommended Reading

Understanding of developmental language disorder in children
MDedge Psychiatry
Positive top-line phase 3 data for lecanemab in early Alzheimer’s
MDedge Psychiatry
More on varenicline
MDedge Psychiatry
Faulty fences: Blood-brain barrier dysfunction in schizophrenia
MDedge Psychiatry
Generalized anxiety disorder: 8 studies of psychosocial interventions
MDedge Psychiatry
Using SNRIs to prevent migraines in patients with depression
MDedge Psychiatry
Lithium, valproate, and suicide risk: Analysis of 98,831 cases
MDedge Psychiatry
Medical record documentation: What to do, and what to avoid
MDedge Psychiatry
COVID pandemic associated with anorexia in Canadian youth
MDedge Psychiatry
Postop analgesia in Saudi Arabia and the United States: A resident’s perspective
MDedge Psychiatry