Cases That Test Your Skills
A mysterious case of mania
Mrs. P appears manic and agitated. She has no psychiatric history but is taking antidepressants and multiple drugs for chronic back pain. How...
Matthew J. Davis, MD
Assistant Professor of Psychiatry
Dartmouth’s Geisel School of Medicine
Staff Psychiatrist
New Hampshire
Hospital, Concord, New Hampshire
Alexander de Nesnera, MD
Associate Professor of Psychiatry
Dartmouth’s Geisel School of Medicine
Associate Medical Director
New Hampshire Hospital
Concord, New Hampshire
David G. Folks, MD
Professor of Psychiatry
Dartmouth’s Geisel School of Medicine
Chief Medical Officer
New Hampshire Hospital, Concord, New Hampshire
Mr. A, age 68, goes on spending sprees and exhibits delusions and auditory hallucinations. Neurocognitive testing reveals severe dysfunction. What could be causing his symptoms?
CASE Nearly naked
Mr. A, age 68, is found sitting in his car, wearing only a jacket, underpants, and boots. He speaks of spreading a message about Osama bin Laden and “taking a census.” Police officers bring him to a hospital emergency department for evaluation.
The examining clinician determines that Mr. A is a danger to himself and others because of mental illness, leading to admission to our state psychiatric hospital.
Mr. A’s wife describes recent spending sprees with large purchases. She had obtained a restraining order against her husband because of his threatening remarks and behaviors. Within days of the order issuance, he got a home equity loan and purchased a $300,000 house.
The medical history is notable for type 2 diabetes mellitus. Although he is not taking medications, his blood sugar is well controlled. Other than an initial resting heart rate of 116 beats per minute, vital signs are stable and within normal limits. Physical examination is unremarkable. Screening laboratory studies are notable for mildly elevated hepatic function, which approaches normal range several days after admission.
Mr. A reports a remote history of alcohol abuse but says he had not been drinking recently, and does not detail his pattern of use. Urine toxicology screen is negative for all substances of abuse.
Mental status examination reveals disheveled appearance, motor agitation, pressured speech, labile affect, loosening of associations, grandiose delusions, and auditory hallucinations. Mr. A’s thought processes are grossly disorganized, such that we could not gather a meaningful history. He believes God is speaking directly to him about plans to build a carousel at Disney World. He makes strange gestures with his hands throughout the interview, as if attempting to trace the shapes of letters and numbers. He frequently speaks of seeing an array of colors. Cognitive examination reveals a score of 5 of 30 on the Montreal Cognitive Assessment (Figure 1), indicating a severe impairment in neurocognitive functioning. He demonstrates limited insight and markedly impaired judgment, and denies having a mental illness.
What should be the next step in managing Mr. A?
a) obtain records from other facilities and collateral history
b) start an antipsychotic
c) order a brain MRI
d) start an alcohol withdrawal protocol
The authors’ observations
Mr. A showed elements of mania, psychosis, and delirium. We considered a broad differential diagnosis (Table). Mr. A initially could not provide reliable or accurate information. The least invasive next step was to obtain additional history from his wife and other medical records to refine the differential diagnosis.
HISTORY Bizarre behavior
Mr. A allows staff to speak with his wife and obtain records from a psychiatric hospitalization 3 years earlier. Mrs. A reports significant and rapid changes in her husband’s behavior and personality over 3 months, but does not describe a recent alcohol relapse. Mr. A sleeps very little, remaining awake and active throughout the night. He frequently rearranges the furniture in their home for no clear reason. Once, he knocked on the door of a young female neighbor asking if she found him attractive.
Mr. A has a significant criminal history. Approximately 30 years ago, he was charged with attempted murder of his ex-wife and he had faced charges of attempted kidnapping and assaulting a police officer. However, he has no recent legal issues.
Mr. A has a history of episodes that are similar to this presentation. Seven years ago, he impulsively purchased a $650,000 house after his fourth wife died. He then had a $90,000 heart-shaped pool installed. He also drove a tractor through his stepdaughter’s car for no apparent reason. Also, 3 years ago, he displayed symptoms similar to his current presentation, including insomnia, irritability, and grandiosity. He engaged in strange behaviors, such as dressing up and imitating homeless people at his church.
During the hospitalization 3 years ago, clinicians gave Mr. A a diagnosis of bipolar disorder, current episode manic, and delirium of an unclear cause. A medical workup, including brain MRI, did not uncover a basis for his delirium. Antipsychotics (risperidone and perphenazine) and mood stabilizers (lithium and valproic acid), stabilized his condition; after 7 weeks, Mr. A was discharged, but he did not pursue outpatient psychiatric care.
What is the most likely DSM-5 diagnosis?
a) major neurocognitive disorder (dementia)
b) alcohol use disorder (eg, Wernicke- Korsakoff syndrome)
c) delirium secondary to mania
d) psychotic disorder
The authors’ observations
DSM-51 suggests a stepwise approach to diagnosis, with consideration of:
• signs and symptoms
• substance use
• general medical condition
• developmental conflict or stage
• whether a mental disorder is present.
Mrs. P appears manic and agitated. She has no psychiatric history but is taking antidepressants and multiple drugs for chronic back pain. How...