Amniotic tissue also possesses potential for chondrogenesis. Cryopreserved human amniotic membrane cells used for in vitro human osteoarthritis tissue scaffolds did not differentiate in culture, and they integrated and repaired damaged articular cartilage.23 Various in vitro24,25 and animal in vivo26,27 studies have reported similar supportive findings. Kunisaki and colleagues28 used sheep amniotic fluid mesenchymal stem cells to reconstruct lamb tracheal cartilage in utero, concluding that cells obtained from the amniotic fluid possess chondrogenic capabilities. Further in utero lamb studies of cartilage artificial defects, given 7 days to settle before adding a hypocellular matrix as a scaffold, showed chondrocyte density and cell architecture was restored at the defect site after 28 days without the formation of an inflammatory response or scar tissue.29
Amniotic tissue has had similar success in tendon repair studies in vivo.9,30,31 Barboni and colleagues32 implanted amniotic epithelial cells (AECs) into artificially created sheep Achilles tendon defects in situ, inducing superior structural and mechanical recovery in the defects at a faster rate compared to controls not receiving AECs. Healing via AECs started at the healthy tissue around the borders of the defect and progressed centrally, suggesting recruitment of native progenitor cells to the lesion.32 Kueckelhaus and colleagues33 investigated the role of amnion-derived cellular cytokine solution in the healing of transections of rat Achilles tendons, reporting improved mechanical properties of healing tendons at early time points compared to controls. Beredjiklian and colleagues34 compared the healing of transected extensor tendons of pregnant ewes and of their fetus in utero, reporting a reparative form of healing with scar formation in adult subjects and regenerative form of healing without scar formation or inflammation in fetal subjects.
Amniotic tissue has properties that prevent adhesion formation around tendons following injury and reconstruction.35 Ozgenel36 investigated the effects of hyaluronic acid and amniotic membrane alone and in combination on the presence of adhesions and the rate of healing following chicken flexor tendon repair. The study found amniotic membrane wrapped around the repaired tendon was superior in preventing adhesion formation. Kim and colleagues37 report a similar reduction in fibrosis and adhesion following application of a human amniotic membrane wrap to rabbit ulnar neurorrhaphy sites.
This barrier function of amniotic tissue has also been investigated in the prevention of surgical scarring and peridural fibrosis in animal models following spinal discectomy. A study in canine models showed a reduction of scarring following the application of cross-linked amniotic membrane compared to freeze dried amniotic membrane.38 Similar reductions in scarring in rat models with the application of freeze-dried amniotic membrane compared to negative controls have been reported.39
Human Studies
A randomized trial investigated the outcomes of prenatal vs postnatal repair of myelomeningocele in humans, finding a reduced need for implanted shunts and improved functional outcomes at 30 months of life in the prenatal intervention group compared to the postnatal group.40 This study was concluded early due to the efficacy of prenatal surgery and the benefit of nervous system repair in utero in the presence of amniotic growth factors.
Vines and colleagues41 performed a 6-patient feasibility study using amnion injections to treat symptomatic knee osteoarthritis. Each patient received a single intra-articular cryopreserved amniotic suspension allograft (ASA) injection and was followed for 1 year. No adverse outcomes were reported, with the only abnormal finding being a small increase in serum immunoglobulin G and immunoglobulin E levels. Intra-articular ASA injection was found to be safe, but a large-scale trial investigating symptomatic relief was recommended.41
Most of the human studies using amnion pertain to foot and ankle surgery. Its use as a treatment for diabetic foot ulcers and recalcitrant plantar fasciitis was one of the early-recognized successes.42-45 Zelen and colleagues46 investigated the applications of injectable micronized dehydrated human amniotic/chorionic membrane as an alternative to surgical intervention in the treatment of refractory plantar fasciitis. This prospective, randomized trial with 45 patients showed significant improvement in plantar fasciitis symptoms at 8 weeks compared to controls (saline injections). A similar study compared the use of cryopreserved human amniotic membrane (c-hAM) injections to corticosteroid injections in plantar fasciitis patients.47 The results indicated that c-hAM is safe and comparable to corticosteroids, with the authors noting that pain improvement was greatest in patients receiving 2 injections of c-hAM at 18 weeks.
Tendon wrapping, in which the amniotic membrane is laid over a tendon repair, has been reported with success. Amniotic membrane is superior to collagen for tendon wrapping as it actively contributes to healing while minimizing adhesions, which collagen alone cannot do.48 The membrane serves as a protective sheath around repaired tendons with anti-inflammatory, anti-adhesive, immunomodulatory, and antimicrobial benefits. A 124-patient study demonstrated the safety of using amnion in this manner, and the authors reported a decreased rate of complication compared to previously published data.49 Another study of 14 patients undergoing foot and ankle surgery with tendon wrapping reported clinical improvement with reduced pain and greater functional outcomes postoperatively compared to preoperative measurements.50