Clinical Edge Journal Scan

Partial breast irradiation vs. whole breast irradiation for early breast cancer


 

Key clinical point: Rates of ipsilateral breast tumor recurrence (IBTR) were similar between partial breast irradiation (PBI) and whole breast irradiation (WBI). Acute skin toxicities were lower with PBI.

Major finding: The rate of IBTR at 5 years was not different between PBI (1.8%; 95% highest posterior density [HPD], 0.68%-3.2%) and WBI (1.7%; 95% HPD, 0.92%-2.4%). Rates of grade 2 or greater acute skin toxicity were lower with PBI (7.1%; 95% HPD, 0%-63.4%) vs. WBI (47.5%; 95% HPD, 0%-93.4%).

Study details: Meta-analysis of 7 randomized trials including 9,758 patients receiving either WBI (n=4,840) or PBI (n=4,918).

Disclosures: No funding source was identified. The lead author reported ties with Impedimed, PreludeDX, Varian Medical Systems, and Vision RT. Some other coinvestigators reported receiving grants or consultation fees from various pharmaceutical companies.

Source: Shah C et al. Ann Surg Oncol. 2021 Jan 3. doi: 10.1245/s10434-020-09447-w.

Recommended Reading

First mammography guidelines for older breast cancer survivors
Breast Cancer ICYMI
Model predicts acute kidney injury in cancer patients a month in advance
Breast Cancer ICYMI
COVID-19 vaccination in cancer patients: NCCN outlines priorities
Breast Cancer ICYMI
Obesity ‘clearly’ not tied to worse survival in metastatic breast cancer
Breast Cancer ICYMI
Findings could change breast cancer risk management
Breast Cancer ICYMI
Aspirin linked to reduced bladder, breast cancer mortality
Breast Cancer ICYMI
Study flags cardiovascular disease in men with breast cancer
Breast Cancer ICYMI
Product update: Breast biopsy system, tamponade mini-sponge, ovulation prediction device and app
Breast Cancer ICYMI
How does long-term OC use affect breast, ovarian, and endometrial cancer risk?
Breast Cancer ICYMI
Clinical Edge Commentary: Breast Cancer February 2021
Breast Cancer ICYMI