Environmental Dermatology

What’s Eating You? Black Butterfly (Hylesia nigricans)

Author and Disclosure Information

Lepidopterism refers to the adverse medical effects of contact with insects of the order Lepidoptera, which includes both moths and butterflies. These effects typically result from contact with an insect during the caterpillar (larval) stage. Lepidopterism involves multiple pathologic mechanisms, including direct toxicity of venom and mechanical irritant effects. Clinical patterns associated with contact with lepidoptera include localized stinging reactions, papular urticaria and dermatitis, urticarial wheals, and hemorrhagic diathesis. Accurate diagnosis of symptoms associated with contact with caterpillars, butterflies, or moths is nearly impossible without a reliable history of exposure, as the histology of exposure is nonspecific. Treatment is largely empiric and should be based on symptoms. We report a case of lepidopterism in a patient with acute cutaneous lesions following exposure to an adult-stage black butterfly (Hylesia nigricans).

Practice Points

  • When contact with caterpillars, butterflies, or moths occurs, patients should be advised not to rub or scratch the area or attempt to remove or crush the insect with a bare hand, as this may further spread irritating setae or spines.
  • Careful removal of the larva with forceps or a similar instrument, combined with tape stripping of the area and immediate washing with soap and water, can be effective in minimizing exposure.
  • Contaminated clothing should be removed and laundered thoroughly.


 

References

The order Lepidoptera (phylum Arthropoda, class Hexapoda) is comprised of moths and butterflies.1 Lepidopterism refers to a range of adverse medical conditions resulting from contact with these insects, typically during the caterpillar (larval) stage. It involves multiple pathologic mechanisms, including direct toxicity of venom and mechanical irritant effects.2 Erucism has been defined as any reaction caused by contact with caterpillars or any reaction limited to the skin caused by contact with caterpillars, butterflies, or moths. Lepidopterism can mean any reaction to caterpillars or moths, referring only to reactions from contact with scales or hairs from adult moths or butterflies, or referring only to cases with systemic signs and symptoms (eg, rhinoconjunctival or asthmatic symptoms, angioedema and anaphylaxis, hemorrhagic diathesis) with or without cutaneous findings, resulting from contact with any lepidopteran source.1 Strictly speaking, erucism should refer to any reaction from caterpillars and lepidopterism to reactions from moths or butterflies. Because reactions to both larval and adult lepidoptera can cause a variety of either cutaneous and/or systemic symptoms, classifying reactions into erucism or lepidopterism is only of academic interest.1

We report a documented case of lepidopterism in a patient with acute cutaneous lesions following exposure to an adult-stage black butterfly (Hylesia nigricans).

Case Report

A 21-year-old oil well worker presented with pruritic skin lesions on the right arm and flank of 3 hours’ duration. He reported that a black butterfly had perched on his arm while he was working and left a considerable number of small yellowish hairs on the skin, after which an intense pruritus and skin lesions began to develop. He denied other associated symptoms. Physical examination revealed numerous 1- to 2-mm, nonconfluent, erythematous and edematous papules on the right forearm, arm (Figure 1A), and flank. Some abrasions of the skin due to scratching and crusting were noted (Figure 1B). A skin biopsy from the right arm showed a superficial perivascular dermatitis with a mixed infiltrate of polymorphonuclear predominance with eosinophils (Figure 2A). Importantly, a structure resembling an urticating spicule was identified in the stratum corneum (Figure 2B); spicules are located on the abdomen of arthropods and are associated with an inflammatory response in human skin.

nonconfluent, erythematous and edematous papules on the right arm

Figure 1. A, Numerous 1- to 2-mm, nonconfluent, erythematous and edematous papules on the right arm. B, Some abrasions of the skin due to scratching and crusting were noted.

perivascular dermatitis with a mixed infiltrate of polymorphonuclear predominance with eosinophils present

Figure 2. A, A biopsy revealed a superficial perivascular dermatitis with a mixed infiltrate of polymorphonuclear predominance with eosinophils present (H&E, original magnification ×40). B, A structure resembling an urticating spicule was identified in the stratum corneum (H&E, original magnification ×20).

Based on the patient’s history of butterfly exposure, clinical presentation of the lesions, and histopathologic findings demonstrating the presence of the spicules, the diagnosis of lepidopterism was confirmed. The patient was treated with oral antihistamines and topical steroids for 1 week with complete resolution of the lesions.

Comment

Epidemiology of Envenomation
Although many tropical insects carry infectious diseases, cutaneous injury can occur by other mechanisms, such as dermatitis caused by contact with the skin (erucism or lepidopterism). Caterpillar envenomation is common, but this phenomenon rarely has been studied due to few reported cases, which hinders a complete understanding of the problem.3

The order Lepidoptera comprises 2 suborders: Rhopalocera, with adult specimens that fly during the daytime (butterflies), and Heterocera, which are largely nocturnal (moths). The stages of development include egg, larva (caterpillar), pupa (chrysalis), and adult (imago), constituting a holometabolic life cycle.4 Adult butterflies and moths represent the reproductive stage of lepidoptera.

The pathology of lepidopterism is attributed to contact with fluids such as hemolymph and secretions from the spicules, with histamine being identified as the main causative component.3 During the reproductive stage, female insects approach light sources and release clouds of bristles from their abdomens that can penetrate human skin and cause an irritating dermatitis.5 Lepidopterism can occur following contact with bristles from insects of the Hylesia genus (Saturniidae family), such as in our patient.3,6 Epidemic outbreaks have been reported in several countries, mainly Argentina, Brazil, and Venezuela.5 The patient was located in Colombia, a country without any reported cases of lepidopterism from the black butterfly (H nigricans). Cutaneous reactions to lepidoptera insects come in many forms, most commonly presenting as a mild stinging reaction with a papular eruption, pruritic urticarial papules and plaques, or scaly erythematous papules and plaques in exposed areas.7

Histopathologic Findings
The histology of lepidoptera exposure is nonspecific, typically demonstrating epidermal edema, superficial perivascular lymphocytic infiltrate, and eosinophils. Epidermal necrosis and vasculitis rarely are seen. Embedded spines from Hylesia insects have been described.7 The histopathologic examination generally reveals a foreign body reaction in addition to granulomas.3

Therapy
The use of oral antihistamines is indicated for the control of pruritus, and topical treatment with cold compresses, baths, and corticosteroid creams is recommended.3,8,9

Conclusion

We report the case of a patient with lepidopterism, a rare entity confirmed histologically with documentation of a spicule in the stratum corneum in the patient’s biopsy. Changes due to urbanization and industrialization have a closer relationship with various animal species that are pathogenic to humans; therefore, we encourage dermatologists to be aware of these diseases.

Recommended Reading

Erythematous Abdominal Nodule
MDedge Dermatology
Patch Testing 101, Part 1: Performing the Test
MDedge Dermatology
A teen presents with a severe, tender rash on the extremities
MDedge Dermatology
Orbital Granuloma Formation Following Autoinjection of Paraffin Oil: Management Considerations
MDedge Dermatology
Palmoplantar Eruption in a Patient With Mercury Poisoning
MDedge Dermatology
Umbilicated Neoplasm on the Chest
MDedge Dermatology
Foreign-Body Reaction to Orthopedic Hardware a Decade After Implantation
MDedge Dermatology
Patch Testing 101, Part 2: After the Patch Test
MDedge Dermatology
Contact Allergy to Nickel: Still #1 After All These Years
MDedge Dermatology
Testosterone Pellet–Induced Generalized Drug Eruption
MDedge Dermatology