Although stage-A heart failure patients are clearly the types of people most often seen and cared for by PCPs, many of these physicians, as well as many heart failure specialists, don’t consider patients who have only hypertension or only diabetes or only obesity as yet having heart failure. That paradox deserves more discussion, but the best way to begin talking about PCPs and heart failure patients is when patients are symptomatic and have what everyone would agree is heart failure.
Dr. Mary Norine Walsh
Even though the ACC/AHA staging system places stage C patients well down the heart failure road, stage C is usually when patients are first diagnosed with heart failure. Although the diagnosis is often first made by a hospitalist or emergency-department physician when severe and sudden-onset heart failure symptoms drive the patient to a hospital, or the diagnosis originates with a cardiologist or heart failure specialist when the patient’s presentation and differential diagnosis isn’t straightforward, most commonly the diagnosis starts with a PCP in an office encounter with a patient who is symptomatic but not acutely ill.
“Patients with shortness of breath or other forms of effort intolerance most often seek care from PCPs. The differential diagnosis of dyspnea is long and complex. Recognition that a patient with dyspnea may have HF is crucial” for timely management and treatment, said Dr. Mary Norine Walsh, medical director of Heart Failure and Cardiac Transplantation at St. Vincent Heart Center in Indianapolis.
At the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn., “most of the heart failure diagnoses are done by PCPs, usually first identified at stage C when a patient comes in with symptoms. Stage B heart failure is usually only identified as an incidental finding when echocardiography is done for some other reason,” said Dr. Paul M. McKie, a heart failure cardiologist who works closely with the primary-care staff at Mayo as an embedded consultant cardiologist.
Mitchel L. Zoler/Frontline Medical News
Dr. Mariell L. Jessup
According to Dr. Mariell L. Jessup, a heart failure physician and professor at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia, a key to PCPs promptly identifying patients with recent-onset, stage C heart failure is to keep the disease as well as its prominent risk factors at the top of their differential-diagnosis list for at-risk patients. “Heart failure is a common disorder,” Dr. Jessup said, and must be considered for patients with shortness of breath. “The leading causes of heart failure are hypertension, obesity, and diabetes. So keep heart failure in mind, especially for patients with one or more of these risk factors.”
Although PCPs might order an echocardiography examination or a lab test like measurement of brain natriuretic protein (BNP) to help nail down the diagnosis, they often leave reading the echocardiography results to a cardiologist colleague. “When a PCP orders an echo it’s automatically read by a cardiologist, and then we get the cardiologist’s report. I don’t read echos myself,” said Dr. Rebecca J. Cunningham, an internal medicine PCP at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston who frequently sees patients with heart failure as medical director of the hospital’s Integrated Care Management Program. “I had one PCP colleague who undertook additional training to learn to read echos himself, but that’s unusual.”
Dr. Mary Ann Bauman, an internal medicine PCP and medical director for Women’s Health and Community Relations at INTEGRIS Health in Oklahoma City, noted a similar division of labor. “If a patient has shortness of breath, maybe some edema, and I hear a few rales, but is totally functional, I always order an echo but I don’t read it. I refer the echo to a cardiologist who then sends me a report,” Dr. Bauman said in an interview. “If I think the patient may have heart failure I’ll also order a BNP or NT-proBNP test. If I suspect heart failure and the BNP is high, it’s a red flag. BNP is another tool for getting the diagnosis right.”
Dr. Mary Ann Bauman
The next step seems much more variable. Some PCPs retain primary control of heart failure management for many of their patients, especially when stage C patients remain stable and functional on simple, straightforward treatment and particularly when they have heart failure with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF), usually defined as a left ventricular ejection fraction that is at least 40%-45%. Consultation or referral to a cardiologist or heart-failure physician seems much more common for patients with frequent decompensations and hospitalizations or patients with heart failure with reduced ejection fraction (HFrEF). But the main thread reported by both PCPs and cardiologists is that it all depends and varies for each patient and for each PCP depending on what patient responsibilities a PCP feels comfortable taking on.