Q&A

Popular diets equally effective for losing weight

Author and Disclosure Information

  • Clinical Question: Which of 4 popular diets (Atkins, Zone, Weight Watchers, and Ornish) is most effective for losing weight and reducing cardiac risk factors?
  • Study Design: Randomized controlled trial (single-blinded)
  • Allocation: Concealed
  • Setting: Outpatient (specialty)
  • Synopsis: Every week it seems as if somebody publishes another diet book that claims to be the best method for losing weight and keeping it off. In fact, very little data addresses the health effects of popular diets and even less data directly compares different diets.


 

Bottom Line

All 4 diets are equally effective for helping adults lose weight and reduce cardiac risk factors. Since success in this study directly correlated with adherence to the diet, it makes sense to help patients choose the diet that is easiest for them to follow, and not preferentially encourage one diet over any other. (LOE=1b–)

Recommended Reading

Conivaptan Reverses Hyponatremia, Studies Show
MDedge Family Medicine
Low Relative Lymphocyte Count Flags Cardiomyopathy Risk
MDedge Family Medicine
Bare-Metal Stents Match Bypass in 5-Year Mortality
MDedge Family Medicine
Prior Oxygen Boost May Aid Post-CABG Cognition
MDedge Family Medicine
Cardiovascular Risks Rising in Native Americans
MDedge Family Medicine
Late Thrombosis Haunts Drug-Eluting Stents
MDedge Family Medicine
Drug-Eluting Stents Meet Cost-Effectiveness Standards
MDedge Family Medicine
Natural Supplements Can Help Lower Lipids
MDedge Family Medicine
Poor Kidney Function Augurs Anemia in HF
MDedge Family Medicine
Encouraging Results From New Platelet Inhibitor
MDedge Family Medicine