From the Journals

Two-test sequence identifies sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob with 100% sensitivity, specificity

View on the News

Practical, accurate test at last

At last we have a truly practical, inexpensive, and accurate procedure for diagnosing sporadic CJD, thanks to the impeccably conducted and convincing work of Dr. Bongianni and associates.

Testing the CSF and then the olfactory mucosa using the RT-QuIC assay should soon become the standard approach for diagnosing CJD, possibly replacing current CSF tests for 14-3-3 and tau proteins. This assay also could be extended to an even larger patient population if it is included in routine laboratory examinations of all patients who have mental/behavioral or cerebellar signs, regardless of their presumed diagnosis.

Because only four of eight mutation-positive symptomatic patients with genetic forms of prion disease tested positive, there may be some future cases of sporadic CJD with false-negative test results or it may be the case that genetic forms have a different timing and spread of misfolded prion protein through the CSF and nasal mucosa.

Paul Brown, MD, is a retired senior investigator at the Laboratory of Central Nervous System Studies at the National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Md. He reported having no relevant financial disclosures. Dr. Brown made these remarks in an accompanying editorial (JAMA Neurol. 2016 Dec 12. doi: 10.1001/jamaneurol.2016.4877).


 

FROM JAMA NEUROLOGY

The sequential use of two diagnostic tests – one assessing cerebrospinal fluid and the other assessing nasal swabs – identifies sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease with virtually 100% sensitivity and specificity, according to a report published online Dec. 12 in JAMA Neurology.

“Patients with sporadic CJD show great variability in clinical signs and pathologic lesions,” which makes distinguishing the disorder from other neurodegenerative abnormalities challenging. Researchers assessed the performance of two diagnostic tests in a case-control study involving 86 patients referred because of clinical suspicion of CJD, 81 control subjects who had other neurologic disorders, and 23 control subjects who had no neurologic disorders. The final diagnoses of the 86 case patients were established either at postmortem examination or when a definite alternative diagnosis was made, said Matilde Bongianni, PhD, of the department of neurosciences, biomedicine, and movement sciences at the University of Verona (Italy) and associates.

A computer graphic of a blue-colored brain. ©Jana Blaková/Thinkstock
The case patients included 37 men and 49 women with a mean age of 65.7 years. A total of 69 of them were definitively diagnosed as having definite or probable CJD (61 patients) or a genetic prion disease (8 patients), while 17 were definitively diagnosed as having some other cause for their symptoms.

The first diagnostic test was a second-generation real-time quaking-induced conversion (RT-QuIC) assay that detects femtograms of an abnormal CJD-specific prion protein in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), which has been reported to have a diagnostic sensitivity of 96%. The second diagnostic test applied the RT-QuIC to brushings from the olfactory mucosa using a soft, flocked nasal swab rather than the more invasive and painful cytobrush, which has been reported to have a diagnostic sensitivity of 97%.

By using these two tests sequentially, the investigators were able to identify all cases of CJD and distinguish affected patients from all the control subjects. Alternative diagnoses were immediately pursued in the 17 case patients in whom CJD was ruled out, and 5 of them were successfully treated for other abnormalities, the investigators said (JAMA Neurol. 2016 Dec 12. doi: 10.1001/jamaneurol.2016.4614).

“Our results suggest that the application of RT-QuIC testing will improve the accuracy and speed of sporadic CJD diagnosis compared with internationally recognized antemortem diagnostic criteria,” Dr. Bongianni and associates wrote.

“A positive RT-QuIC finding in the CSF of patients with progressive neurologic signs should be sufficient to establish a diagnosis of probable CJD and would make olfactory mucosa sampling unnecessary. However, when the RT-QuIC CSF finding is negative or lumbar puncture is not feasible, olfactory mucosa sampling would become necessary to confirm prion disease or to divert to alternative diagnoses,” they added.

The study was supported by the Alliance Biosecure Foundation, the University of Verona, and the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases. The investigators reported having no relevant financial disclosures.

Recommended Reading

Amyloid PET scans may have clinical utility in patients with cognitive impairment
MDedge Family Medicine
Blood pressure changes and persistent hypertension elevate dementia risk
MDedge Family Medicine
Home-based intervention improves cognitive impairment in cancer survivors
MDedge Family Medicine
VIDEO: Blood pressure and LDL lowering in elderly do not slow cognitive decline
MDedge Family Medicine
ADT not associated with increased risk of dementia in larger study
MDedge Family Medicine
Legislators commit to bipartisan support of Alzheimer’s funding
MDedge Family Medicine
Dementia prevalence increased in heart failure patients
MDedge Family Medicine
Nonalcoholic fatty liver disease accelerates brain aging
MDedge Family Medicine
After full data release, experts say failed Alzheimer’s trial EXPEDITION 3 offers hopeful signals
MDedge Family Medicine
TauRx still rooting for its methylene blue AD drug, despite controversial study results
MDedge Family Medicine