News
DACA: High Court ruling could squash dreams of becoming a doctor
More medical schools are accepting undocumented immigrants, but the training could be at risk if the U.S. Supreme Court strikes down protections...
President Trump has ended the Obama administration’s Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, a policy that protected immigrants who came to the United States as children from deportation and authorized them to work in the United States.
In a Sept. 5 press conference, Attorney General Jeff Sessions called the DACA program an unconstitutional overreach of executive branch power by the former administration that deliberately sought to undermine the legislative branch. Rollback of the DACA program will begin immediately, Mr. Sessions said, with the program expiring completely on March 5, 2018.
Wikimedia Commons/Seattle City Council/ CCO Attribution 2.0 Generic
“The effect of this unilateral executive amnesty, among other things, contributed to a surge of minors at the southern border that yielded terrible humanitarian consequences,” Mr. Sessions said during the press conference. “[DACA has] also denied jobs to hundreds of thousands of Americans by allowing those same illegal aliens to take those jobs. To have a lawful system of immigration that serves the national interest, we cannot admit everyone. Therefore the nation must set and enforce a limit on how many immigrants we admit and that means all cannot be accepted.”
In a statement issued shortly after the press conference, President Trump said winding down the DACA program is in the nation’s best interest, and that there can be no principled immigration reform if the executive branch is able to “rewrite or nullify federal laws at will.
“As President, my highest duty is to defend the American people and the Constitution of the United States of America,” President Trump said in the statement. “At the same time, I do not favor punishing children, most of whom are now adults, for the actions of their parents. But we must also recognize that we are nation of opportunity because we are a nation of laws.”
The DACA program was created by the Obama administration in 2012 as a way of protecting young, undocumented immigrants from deportation after Congress repeatedly blocked legislation that would develop such a safe haven. The policy allowed about 800,000 young adults brought to the United States illegally as children to work legally in the U.S. and remain in the country without the fear of deportation.
The program’s end will affect the growing number of medical students with DACA status and likely jeopardize the funding invested in their training. Sixty-two medical schools accept applications from DACA applicants, according to the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC). For the 2016 -2017 school year, 113 students with DACA status applied to US medical schools, and there were 65 medical students enrolled who had DACA status. AAMC does not collect data on medical students with DACA status; the National Resident Matching Program, likewise, does not collect data on residents with DACA status.
Loyola University in Chicago is one institute that could be significantly impacted by recension of DACA. The university has accepted more students with DACA status than any other U.S. medical school, and currently has 32 DACA students attending, said Mark Kuczewski, Ph.D., chair of medical education at Loyola University.
“It’s a tragic decision,” he said in an interview. “It once again puts a cloud over these young people who DACA has given the first real opportunity to come out of the shadows, be educated, and serve the community. Now they’re returned back to the situation of uncertainty.”
The decision to end DACA means that current DACA medical students may not be able to finish their training and that those close to completion may not be able to use their degrees in the workforce, Dr. Kuczewski said. Since they are not citizens, DACA students do not qualify for federal student loans, so medical schools must find ways to help DACA students finance their education. A major Catholic health system provides student loan packages for several DACA students at Loyola’s Stritch School of Medicine, Dr. Kuczewski said. However, such loan programs require DACA status. Without DACA or another path to citizenship, medical students in the middle of training will not be able to obtain financial aid to finish their training, he said. The work authorization that DACA provided will also be eliminated.
Dr. Kuczewski said his university plans to advocate strongly for Congress to pass legislation to protect DACA youth, such as the Dream Act of 2017.
“We are going to advocate strongly because we believe this is common sense,” he said. “You don’t just throw away the talents of these young people and the investments they’ve made in their education and the investments we’ve made in them. DACA has given many people the chance to see these young people as students, as employees, as colleagues, and we hope that helps people to mobilize.”
In a statement, Jack Ende, MD, president of the American College of Physicians, said President Trump’s decision to end the DACA program threatens to deny the country the talents of more than half a million individuals making enormous contributions and will also undermine public health and medical education.
“Today’s executive order has the potential to gravely impact public health,” Dr. Ende said in the statement. “We know that noncitizens and undocumented immigrants are more likely to lack health insurance coverage. If the nearly 800,000 people who are currently benefiting from DACA have their protections removed, many will avoid seeking health care in order to reduce the risk of detection and deportation. … Those who seek to serve in the health care professions will be denied that opportunity.”
The Immigration Reform Law Institute praised President Trump’s decision to rescind the DACA program, calling the policy an affront to Congress and a violation of the U.S. Constitution.
“Contrary to former President Obama’s claims, not only is DACA not authorized by federal statute, but prior to the unlawful program, deferred action has only ever been applied to small numbers of illegal aliens on a case-by-case basis,” Dale Wilcox, executive director, said in a statement. “Applying it to approximately 15% of the illegal alien population was never a proper exercise of the president’s discretion under the Constitution and is inconsistent with the president’s duty to take care that the laws be faithfully executed. By rescinding DACA, President Trump has put an end to the previous administration’s flagrant violation of our immigration laws and its abuse of hard-working American taxpayers.”
In a memorandum issued Sept. 5, the Department of Homeland Security said it will begin winding down the DACA program, while providing a limited window in which it will adjudicate certain requests for DACA and associated applications. DHS will adjudicate, on an individual, case-by-case basis, properly filed pending DACA initial requests and associated applications for employment authorization documents that have been accepted by the department as of Sept.5, 2017, according to the memorandum. All DACA initial requests and associated applications filed after this date will be rejected.
On Twitter @legal_med