SEATTLE — Education and the collaborative efforts of a team of professionals are important for preventing the female athlete triad, according to Sharon H. Thompson, Ed.D.
The definition of the female athlete triad has been expanded recently, said Dr. Thompson, professor of health promotion at the Coastal Carolina University in Conway, S.C. Previously, the triad was viewed as consisting of disordered eating, amenorrhea, and osteoporosis. Now, athletes are considered to be affected if they have low energy, menstrual disorders, and low bone mineral density.
“The extent of disordered eating in athletes is really unclear,” Dr. Thompson said at an international conference sponsored by the Academy for Eating Disorders. Studies suggest that perhaps two-thirds of female athletes are affected. Athletes who are not consuming enough calories often become deficient in nutrients as well, and some of these (calcium, vitamin D, vitamin K, phosphorus, magnesium, and fluoride) are critical for bone health, she noted.
Amenorrhea in female athletes is associated with a two- to fourfold increased risk of stress fractures, Dr. Thompson said at the conference, which was cosponsored by the University of New Mexico. But they may have other types of menstrual dysfunction, including oligomenorrhea, anovulation, and luteal phase deficiency, which also affects bones.
It would be rare to find a female athlete who has frank osteoporosis, Dr. Thompson noted. However, “we know that athletes who have amenorrhea have 10%–25% lower bone mineral density at their lumbar spine, compared to control athletes. Bone loss may be accelerated in this population by estrogen deficiency, low energy availability, and a decreased rate of new bone formation.
“Bottom line, female athletes should have higher bone mineral density than nonfemale athletes,” she asserted. “Any female athlete who has lower bone mineral density is going to be more at risk for stress fractures and, it is also suggested, possibly more at risk for osteoporosis later on down the line.”
Of note, Dr. Thompson said, the female athlete triad's low energy availability leads to the other two components (menstrual disorders and low bone mineral density), and this has implications for prevention. “It's important that people who work with female athletes not necessarily look for all three of these together,” she stressed. “The low energy intake itself can lead to other problems.” And because the components can occur independently of each other, “prevention efforts are definitely needed for any of these problems.”
A survey that Dr. Thompson conducted among 300 female collegiate cross-country runners found that 83% had body mass indexes within the average category (J. Coll. Health. 2007;56:129–36). Some (19%) had previous or current eating disorders, but only a quarter of this group had ever been treated. In all, 23% had irregular menstrual cycles, and 29% had inadequate calcium intake, raising concerns about bone health. “The conclusion from this study is the importance of nutrition education for athletes, especially in the area of calcium-rich foods that might be added to their diet,” she said.
Educational efforts aimed at preventing the female athlete triad are lacking, according to Dr. Thompson. For example, fewer than 41% of Division I athletic teams and fewer than 33% of high schools have programs for their students that address eating disorders. Moreover, of high schools with such programs, 9% require athletes to attend, and 15% mandate the related education of coaches.
“It's important to realize, when [you screen] for the female athlete triad, that the main priority really should be looking for low energy intake,” Dr. Thompson said. She recommended that screening questions be part of the routine medical history to avoid calling undue attention to them. And athletes suspected of having disordered eating should be interviewed in person and given surveys that have been validated in this population (J. Athl. Train. 2008;43:80–108).
When drafting educational programs for athletes, institutions can refer to guidelines from the National Collegiate Athletic Association and the American College of Sports Medicine, Dr. Thompson said. Such programs should present factual information and resources on eating disorders, nutrition, weight, and menstrual health to avoid any stigmatization, she advised.
In addition, athletes should be made aware that treatment is not only available, but also effective. “I think that when they realize [treatment] can be helpful, and their performance can increase and they can feel better, then that's hopefully very attractive,” she said.
Noting that many coaches lack formal education on the female athlete triad, Dr. Thompson recommended mandatory, comprehensive training for this group at least annually so they are better prepared to prevent, recognize, and deal with the condition.