What Your Patients are Hearing

Schools’ cell phone policies: What’s best for students?


 

Schools across the country – or around the world, for that matter – are grappling with policies and regulations tied to their students’ use of cell phones during school hours.

Skarin/Thinkstock

These policies run the gamut, from allowing students to use smartphones as learning tools to requiring them to keep the devices turned off. One public high school’s action on cell phones, initiated this year by a parent, has prompted one parent’s thumbs-up. This school is phasing in a lock-up-your-cell-phone policy.

NPR reporter Jennifer Ludden said that when the idea was first floated toward the end of the last school year, it provoked a parental outcry at her sons’ school. “My generation is used to 24/7 access to our kids, wherever they are. I confess, I’ve texted mine at school. It was about a doctor’s appointment,” Ms. Ludden says.

Meanwhile, she says, some asked: “ ‘What if there’s an emergency?’ It’s a fair question. We’ve all heard about students hiding from a gunman, posting updates, and texting to let friends and family know they’re safe,” she says.

Yet, evidence suggests that a cell-free classroom is a safer classroom, without the distraction of that screen to divert attention instructions that come in the wake of a school emergency. And, in a chilling mental image, a phone’s ringtone or vibration on a desk could be a beacon for a shooter.

Putting aside the horrific potential of school violence, a no-phone policy could have other tangible benefits that would help students in real life. The rejigging of adolescent brains away from the umbilical cord of their phone would be welcome. Imagine social interactions, instead of that face-down, thumbs-poised posture that is everywhere! And it could also help curb the electronic version of passing notes during tests.

Ms. Ludden mentions another benefit. “My sons will have 6 hours of the day free from the nonstop barrage of bad news alerts … the latest shooting, terror attack, disaster, or potty-mouthed Tweet storm. Invaluable time to relax, and connect, without phones. I’m grateful to see some schools investing in that,” Ms. Ludden says.

Click here to listen to Ms. Ludden’s take.

Recommended Reading

Rapid weight loss, irritability, and nausea after restarting ADHD treatment
MDedge Psychiatry
Interventions ‘key’ when ADHD, conduct disorder, and delinquency overlap
MDedge Psychiatry
Children, adolescents with TBI at risk of secondary ADHD
MDedge Psychiatry
Early reading aloud, play reduced hyperactivity at school entry
MDedge Psychiatry
Anxiety, depression prevalent in children with comorbid autism and ADHD
MDedge Psychiatry
It’s not about time
MDedge Psychiatry
Social media use linked to 10% increase in risk of new ADHD symptoms among teens
MDedge Psychiatry
Methylphenidate deemed best first-line option for ADHD in children
MDedge Psychiatry
Concurrent stimulant and opioid use ‘common’ in adult ADHD
MDedge Psychiatry
Alopecia areata linked to mental health disorders
MDedge Psychiatry