The ABPN, long regarded as an esteemed nonprofit organization, has been accused of being a monopoly. Some angry psychiatrists have filed a class action lawsuit to demand other board certification methods. Some have gone to the media to complain about the American Board of Medical Specialties (of which the ABPN is a member board), accusing both of unfair regulations or of raking in substantial profits to support excessively compensated executives. Perception often trumps reality, so no matter how vigorously the ABPN defends itself, its procedures, or its MOC requirements, its customers—psychiatric physicians—feel oppressed or exploited.
How the MOC can be improved
So what can be done to improve the MOC? The need for recertification is arguably necessary to document clinical competency over an approximately 40-year psychiatric career following residency. I conducted a brief survey of Current Psychiatry readers. Of the 319 respondents, 86.5% recommended abolishing the MOC, while 13.5% said it should remain or were unsure. In a follow-up question, 60% agreed that the American Psychiatric Association (APA) should establish a Council on Board Certification, and 33% agreed that the MOC should only be a clinical vignette-based written exam every 10 years, along with an unrestricted or active state medical license.
Significant advances in remote communication technology should be harnessed by the ABPN (or the APA, if it decides to conduct its own board certification) to restore the old model at a fraction of the cost. The oral exams have been replaced by a written exam that is not an accurate reflection or documentation of clinical competence. The traditional oral exam (after passing a written exam) was a magnificent but costly feat of massive logistical complexity, with >1,000 candidates and examiners traveling to a city where the ABPN arranged for several hospitals to shut down their clinics for 2 full days to use their clinical offices for the oral exams. Multiple teams examined the candidates twice on the same day: once with a live patient, and again with a video of a real patient. The examiners filled out scoring cards after observing the candidates conduct the live interview or discussing the video. A consensus grade of pass or fail was documented. At the end of the 2 days, examiners and candidates boarded buses to the airport. It was a highly expensive process (exam fees + airfare + hotel + food). Twice a year, the examiners generously donated their time to the ABPN without compensation, as a token of love for and service to the profession.
That initial certification of a written exam, followed by an oral exam, validated the competence of a psychiatrist both cognitively and clinically. The lifetime certification was truly earned. The same model can now be replicated virtually via videoconferencing at a far lower cost to the ABPN, the candidates, and the examiners. The MOC 10-year recertification can be reduced to a written exam with clinical vignettes and an unrestricted license to practice medicine in any state, which implies that the psychiatrist has received the 50 CME annual credits to renew the license. The rest of the bells and whistles can be strongly recommended but not required. The cost in time and money to both the ABPN and the candidates can be significantly reduced, but more importantly, the clinical competence will be validated at baseline with virtual oral boards after passing the written exam (formerly labeled as part I, preceding the part II oral boards).
The traditional board certification model of the past should be resurrected via videoconferencing and offered as an option to the candidates who prefer it to the current MOC. The MOC can then be simplified to lifetime certification or to only a written exam with clinical vignettes every 10 years to ensure that psychiatrists continue to incorporate relevant clinical and treatment advances in their practice. The KISS principle (keep it simple, stupid) worked very well for many generations of psychiatrists in the past, and will work again going forward if offered as an option. Psychiatrists can then focus on treating patients instead of being burdened by the many time-consuming requirements and hoops of the current MOC.